Cartoon: Arend van Dam, politicalcartoons.com

It takes a comedian to sum things up accurately. The American late-night host Jimmy Fallon pointed out on NBC’s The Tonight Show that the timing of the trilateral meeting in Shenzhen on November 19th between Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping and Donald Trump made sense: “Now that James Bond has been cast, they’re auditioning villains.” For all the overwrought headlines that framed the encounter as “historic,” the reality was exactly as Fallon quipped.

Which is also why Trump relished this photo opportunity with the two dictators he admires most: These are individual leaders powerful enough to do or say whatever they want without fear of domestic contradiction and who don’t have to subject themselves to such annoying distractions as midterm congressional elections.

These dictators are, he likes to say, his “friends,” disregarding the awkward reality that Russia and China have in fact declared themselves to be dedicated to the undermining of the West, by which they mean America, and are providing finance, technology and weapons to Iran, a country with which Trump himself started a war nine months ago which is still going on.

This was an encounter between two gangster-partners and their rival gang leader to discuss how to pursue their own interests at everyone else’ s expense. The good news is that, as far as we can tell, these three villains did not agree at their meeting on anything of substance. The event was little more than a photo opportunity.

Yet for as long as Trump remains in the White House the very fact of such meetings will be damaging and dangerous as well as being offensive to all the values that the United States of America has stood for since its foundation 250 years ago. Fortunately or unfortunately, however, Trump doesn’t represent America when he swaggers around at meetings like this: he represents himself. There can be no other possible explanation for his disregard of the fact that Russia and China are allied against America and the rest of the West.

Nor for the fact that his personal envoy, the real-estate developer Steve Witkoff, has described Putin publicly as being “a humanitarian.” No one in their right mind could do that, given the extraordinary crimes Putin has committed against Ukraine and against his own people.

A rational actor might choose to consider Putin to be some sort of hard-headed might-is-right realist, sending more than one-and-a-half million Russians to die or be wounded in a war, killing his domestic political opponents and slaughtering Ukrainian civilians for a supposed national purpose. But you would only call him a humanitarian if you were hoping to get some personal advantage out of such absurd, plainly false flattery. And there can be little doubt that Witkoff was told by his boss to say this to Putin.

At least it can be said that the hypocrisy and the parade of falsehoods was shared among all three villains. Xi Jinping declared that the three great powers should “jointly uphold world peace,” even though Russia and America have both started totally unnecessary wars that they remain engaged in. Vladimir Putin claimed that the three powers had a special role in preserving international law, even though he has done more than anyone to break it, an attitude now emulated by the Trump administration.

Outrageously, in a new low even for Trump given his taste for lecturing allies in how they should conduct themselves, his Deputy Secretary of Defense for Policy Elbridge Colby attacked Ukraine at a meeting of NATO leaders on November 17th for actually fighting back against Russian war crimes by using deep strikes against oil refineries in Russia and, in the latest Ukrainian success, the Kerch Bridge that connects Russia with the illegally occupied Ukrainian province of Crimea. There can now be no doubt at all that the Trump administration is working to achieve a Russian victory.

The joint statement from Russia and China – a bit of a clue that they are operating in concert – claimed that “the immunities of state officials are of utmost importance” and warned that the International Criminal Court and other bodies “must not abuse their authority,” even though there is no such principle of immunity for state officials in international law or accepted practice.

Indeed, the most fundamental events in the creation of international law, the Tokyo and Nuremberg war crimes tribunals of 1945, were established by the victorious allies (which included Russia, China and America) expressly to enforce the accountability of state officials for their acts and the acts done in their name.

What all three villains actually have in their minds is immunity for the great powers, and those who lead them, from the laws, rules and norms that apply to everyone else. We can safely assume that when Russia and China call in their joint statement for the reform of the United Nations they do not have in mind that the UN should gain any ability to regulate what they do, nor that there should be any dilution of the veto power that both countries hold as permanent members of the UN Security Council.

In fact, most likely they have no reform in mind at all, at least none that would, in their words, enable it to “respond more effectively to global challenges.” And when they claim they are working for peace, they mean that actually they are working for peace for themselves but fear, violence and coercion for others.

Quite possibly the only statement made by the three villains that should be taken seriously is their pledge to increase the production of petroleum products, for doing so would help Putin continue to finance his war in Ukraine, which is a goal that all three have made plain that they have in common. The idea that Trump has been trying to use sanctions to put pressure on Putin and restrict Russia’s ability to sell its fossil fuels has at last been exposed as a fiction.

In the end, we can console ourselves with the fact that these three villains are nothing like as powerful as they like to make out.

Can we perhaps hope?

They are powerful only when measured by their arsenals of nuclear weapons, which fortunately the Russia-China statement declared must not be used, for “a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought” – in a welcome contrast to the nuclear threats Russia has been making since February 2022 against both Ukraine and the European members of NATO.

We can perhaps hope that this statement was included in order to signal that Russia will no longer make such threats, but given the all-round hypocrisy and array of falsehoods emerging from the summit it would be a mistake to put much weight on that hope.

On other dimensions these three great powers do not look all that great: Russia has failed in a nearly five-year war to defeat its smaller neighbor Ukraine, is riven with corruption and has an economy dependent on yesterday’s energy technology; America has failed to defeat Iran, has exposed clear shortcomings in its military production and has generated the biggest electoral backlash against a ruling administration for half a century; and China has a weak domestic economy and still, after a 14-year anti-corruption purge, is locking more people up, including senior military figures, virtually every month.

President Xi may have looked good and even self-satisfied at the Shenzhen summit, but that is a reflection only of the even lower state of the company he was keeping.

These villain-hypocrites are not the leaders of the world, in any sense. They are flawed, dangerous predators who have only their own interests at heart. They can and must be opposed and deterred, in every way possible. Their choice to meet as a threesome deserves to be described as “historic” only in the sense that it has made clear who the enemies of peace, justice and law really are. That is what this week’s summit will be remembered for, and nothing else.

This article first appeared on Bill Emmott’s Global View Substack and is republished with kind permission. Read the original here and become a subscriber here.

Bill Emmott, a former editor-in-chief of The Economist, is the author of The Fate of the West.

Leave a comment