A rare uncensored app that had attracted Chinese internet users to freely discuss taboo topics including the mass detention of Uighurs, democracy protests in Hong Kong and the concept of Taiwanese independence appeared to have been blocked on Monday night.
Authoritarian China deploys a vast and sophisticated surveillance state to scrub the internet of dissent and prevent citizens from accessing international social networking sites like Facebook and Twitter in what is often known as the “Great Firewall.”
But the Clubhouse app had for a brief while sidestepped the censors and drawn crowds of Chinese internet users – but appears now to have fallen afoul of the censors.
The American invite-only audio app allows users to listen and participate in loosely moderated live conversations in digital “rooms.”
And in recent days, Chinese online users have filled those rooms discussing highly censored subjects – such as Beijing’s sweeping incarceration of mostly Muslim minority Uighur communities in the far western Xinjiang region.
By Monday night, however, the app showed an error message to users who lack virtual private networks so can’t secure their connections, and Chinese-language rooms quickly turned to discussion over the app’s ban.
Top trending groups turned to topics about the ban, and some Chinese language users began to discuss security implications of being on the app and whether they would face official monitoring.
“I saw many rooms chatting cross-Straits issues and sensitive issues … and thought this app wouldn’t last too long,” one Chinese-language user lamented after the app was blocked, referring to the thorny issue of Taiwan.
“What comes after the block is compiling the list of people on the platform,” worried another.
‘The real internet’
Clubhouse was launched in May last year and is currently only available on Apple devices, something only wealthier Chinese consumers can afford.
It rocketed in popularity after billionaire Elon Musk participated in a conversation on the app earlier this month.
Over the weekend the number of Chinese language discussions had drawn wider attention including on social media platform Twitter.
“A young woman from mainland China just said on Clubhouse: ‘This is my first time getting on the real internet,'” Isabelle Niu, a journalist listening to a conversation, tweeted on Sunday.
E-commerce sites including Taobao, a popular online marketplace used by millions daily, were selling membership invitations for sale with prices ranging from 10 to 100 yuan ($1.5-$15), allowing some to bypass restrictions placed on invitations.
Kaiser Kuo, host of the China-focused Sinica Podcast, live-tweeted on Sunday some of the conversations he was hearing in a room discussing the Uighur situation.
He noted how Han Chinese – the dominant ethnic group in China – and people from the persecuted Uighur community were interacting in the space.
An AFP reporter heard a speaker identifying as mainland Chinese express opposition to the term “concentration camps” – although acknowledging the existence of facilities.
Many of those listening in were fascinated by the candor of the online discussions.
“I’m in a Taiwanese-run room in Clubhouse where 4,000 Mandarin speakers — including Uighurs and Han Chinese IN CHINA, and outside are talking about … everything,” Berlin-based journalist Melissa Chan tweeted.
“From surveillance, to friends who’ve left re-educations camps, to normal stuff.”
But analysts had warned that it was likely Beijing would prevent access to the app before long.
“The window for listening in on frank Clubhouse conversations about politics in Chinese is already closing,” Fergus Ryan, at the Australian Strategic Policy Institute’s International Cyber Policy Centre, said ahead of the ban.