Singapore has enacted some of the most wide-reaching anti-fake news legislation in the world. Photo: AFP

Five months after it was passed into law, Singapore’s anti-fake news legislation has taken draconian effect, representing a new threat to online expression and new wrinkle for big technology companies with operations in the city-state.

The Protection from Online Falsehoods and Manipulation Act, more commonly known as POFMA, sparked sharp civil society, academia and large tech company criticism ahead of its passage.

The Asia Internet Coalition described the fake news-related law as the “most far-reaching legislation of its kind to date”, giving the “Singapore government full discretion over what is considered true or false.”

At the same time, observers think it is unlikely that the law – unless frequently and arbitrarily applied – will make much of a dent in Singapore’s attractiveness as a foreign tech investment hub.

Under the newly enacted law, any government minister will have the power to issue directives requiring individuals or companies to post corrections, remove articles or block access to content that they deem contains “false statements of fact” related to the public interest.

Ministers are also under the law able to designate a page that’s received three such orders in a six-month period a so-called “declared online location”— an act that aims to defund a website by barring it from earning income from advertising or subscriptions.

Law Minister K. Shanmugam speaks to journalists in Singapore on December 2, 2016.Photo: AFP/Roslan Rahman

Nor may individuals associated with such designated sites be allowed to derive any financial or other benefits from operating it.

The law also provides for prosecutions of individuals, who can face fines of up to S$50,000 (US$36,000), and, or, up to five years in prison. If the alleged falsehood is posted using “an inauthentic online account or controlled by a bot,” the total potential fine rises to S$100,000 ($73,000), and, or, up to 10 years in prison.

Companies found guilty of spreading fake news can face fines of up to S$1 million ($735,000).

The outcry against the bill failed to halt its passage into law, underscoring the long-ruling People’s Action Party’s (PAP) supermajority control over parliament.

After a two-day marathon debate, 72 PAP MPs voted for the bill; all nine opposition members voted against. Three nominated MPs, who had proposed amendments to constrain the powers of ministers that failed to get adopted, abstained from the vote.

Once the law was passed, big internet and tech companies took a notably more conciliatory tack, with the Asia Internet Coalition promising that they would “work with the Singapore government on the implementation of the POFMA and on promoting digital and media literacy to address and reduce the impact of online falsehoods.”

After the law came into force on October 2, Jeff Paine, managing director of the Asia Internet Coalition, issued a statement saying that the coalition “hopes that POFMA will be enforced with transparency and fairness.”

Terence Lee, chief editor of the website Tech in Asia, told Asia Times that reaction to the passage of the law has been “fairly muted.”

“While social media platforms will no doubt be affected by POFMA, in the larger scheme of things it doesn’t outweigh the benefits of setting up in Singapore to tap on the growth of the internet economy of SEA,” he says.

Facebook uses Singapore as a regional hub for its Southeast Asia operations. Photo: AFP

Major tech companies like Facebook, Twitter, and Google all have significant operations in Singapore. In 2018, Facebook announced that it would invest over US$1 billion to build its first Asian data center in Singapore.

“Obviously, Facebook and Google voiced their concerns about this but they will still comply,” Lee added, noting that Chinese tech companies such as Tik Tok and BIGO, both present in Singapore, are no strangers to stringent government online regulations.

“We’re committed to preventing the spread of misinformation on our services in Singapore, and we’ve taken significant steps this year, rolling out third party fact checking with local partner AFP and launching ‘We Think Digital’, which empowers Singaporeans with critical digital literacy skills,” says Rahimah Abdulrahim, Facebook’s director of public policy in Southeast Asia.

“These initiatives complement our ongoing global work to remove fake accounts, disrupt coordinated inauthentic behavior, and offer more transparency around ads and Pages.”

The PAP government has given the tech companies some leeway with the law. Temporary exemptions were made under subsidiary legislation to give Google, Facebook, Twitter, Baidu and WeChat time to “put in place the necessary arrangements and technological measures to enable them to comply with certain requirements of the Act.”

Complying with government censorship orders could open tech companies up to criticism, yet industry sources say that this isn’t likely enough pressure to push companies into more active resistance.

Facebook, for instance, has already received flak for censorship in Vietnam. A report produced by Facebook earlier this year revealed that in the last half of 2018 it had restricted access to over 500% more content than previously.

Still, Lee doesn’t think the risk of complying with POFMA will be high enough to impact on Facebook’s target markets. “How much of a reputational risk are we talking about, and among which groups of people?” he asks.

“If we’re talking about the general population, they’re just going to flock to where their friends hang out. For [businesses], they’ll buy ads on the platform with the most people relevant to them.”

Despite some initial disquiet, most tech companies aren’t particularly alarmed by the new law’s enactment, industry sources say. As Lee points out, there are still many online companies, such as e-commerce site like Lazada, or payment services like PayPal, that won’t be directly affected by the fake news law.

“People invest in Singapore not because of Singapore’s domestic market. It’s the gateway to the rest of Southeast Asia,” Lee says.

Concerns about the law’s potential abuse are centered instead in Singapore’s independent media scene. The local mainstream media—spanning traditional mediums like print, television and radio, as well as online—is widely seen as influenced by the PAP and skewed in favor of the government’s narratives.

The few independent media outlets that take a more critical view of the ruling party already tend to struggle with funding and resources to pose a serious challenge to pro-establishment media sources. Those that have built strong readerships, meanwhile, often come under official pressure to tone down and censor their news.

Terry Xu, chief editor of Singapore’s longest-running independent news website, The Online Citizen, was sued last month by Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong for defamation for publishing an article that repeated allegations made by his estranged siblings. Under the POFMA, authorities can now deem such articles as fake news and demand they be taken down.

Kumaran says The Independent Singapore, with the new fake law’s passage in sight, has invested substantially over the past year to improve editorial and fact-checking processes.

He, for one, isn’t worried about Singapore’s relationship with foreign tech companies; it’s the local media outfits that are most under threat by the new law, he says.

Singapore’s Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong speaks during the opening of the IISS Shangri-La Dialogue summit in Singapore on May 31, 2019. Photo: Roslan Rahman/AFP

“Make no mistake, POFMA is a tool to control the political narrative in Singapore,” Kumaran warns.

“The big tech firms have both formal and informal communication channels with the Singapore government,” to shield them from the law, he told Asia Times.

“At the same time, the government has put in place severe restrictions on local media start-ups and publicly shames them as traitors and dissidents to keep the copycats out,” he said.

“So we have a situation of local media start-ups not having sufficient capital while foreign media outlets are free to setup shop.”

Asia Times Financial is now live. Linking accurate news, insightful analysis and local knowledge with the ATF China Bond 50 Index, the world's first benchmark cross sector Chinese Bond Indices. Read ATF now. 

Join the Conversation

7 Comments

  1. A ticket you punch is only equal to an application you fill out and equals nothing.

    Treat all people with humanity, because no one forgets the person who
    treated them less then human. Relationships succeed when things are 50 50 and you give 100 percent to meet halfway.
    But Farber writes in such a way that disagreeing with him
    feels liberating rather than constricting. He’s not so much
    dictating opinions as shooting out darts. Even though he’s a very cerebral critic, he’s also unfailingly generous in the way he frees each of us from our own private, personal shame as moviegoers.

    human hair wigs Es posible que tus pechos estn hipersensibles y te duelan al roce,
    especialmente durante el primer trimestre. Esta sensibilidad
    generalmente disminuye con el paso de los meses, pero a menudo los pechos siguen estando ms sensibles de lo
    normal. A algunas mujeres esta sensacin les parece agradable, mientras que otras prefieren que ni se los toquen..
    Timicin is crushed, and after some questioning by Lwaxana, he reveals that there are other things troubling
    him. Timicin tells Lwaxana that he is about to turn 60, and on Kaelon II,
    everyone who reaches that age performs the “Resolution”,
    a ritual act of voluntary euthanasia. Lwaxana is outraged to learn of this and brings
    it to the attention of Captain Jean Luc Picard (Patrick Stewart).
    human hair wigs

    wigs for women Where can you find replacement parts for small appliances?

    First, check your owner’s manual to identify the model and part numbers.
    If you live in or near a metropolitan area,
    you may have a number of appliance parts stores from which to purchase.
    Of course, call them first to determine if they have or can get the type of parts you require.
    Usually people are really nice but they ask some weird questions that makes people uncomfortable.

    The most annoying are when did you come here (and their response
    ohh i have been here for 35yeras), what is your visa/status and some go far by asking are
    you Jordanian Jordanian or Palestinian Jordanian!!. Some just start
    talking crap about Jordan (you don’t look like it but people do that)..
    wigs for women

    wigs for women And i see BN changing that with Br1m, and investments into rural areas.
    Why should kelantan or tganu be denied development?
    if one cancels ecrl, which per news has a 70% local workforce requirement, is
    that not cutting them off?why should urbanites have all
    the say at the expense of rural voters, when all the prosperity thus far has accrued to
    urbanites (myself included)?ArxcesLet do what we can, and not
    worry about things we can 3 points submitted 4 hours
    agoI have a theory that all this fuss about the GST and other issues
    is the M40 finally being asked to pay to help out the B40.

    Previously we had oil revenue that kept us afloat and the M40
    enjoyed the benefits such as the petrol subsidy that disproportionately
    benefitted the large vehicle owners over motorcyclists.I am generalising here,
    but the middle class don like the B40. wigs for women

    tape in extensions Halloween is such a fun holiday dressing up, going out trick or treating.
    But some of the pediatric patients at the Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago, who are in intensive rehabilitation for severe injuries,
    conditions or diseases, aren well enough to leave the hospital for a traditional Halloween.
    Instead, the team at RIC brings the fun to them.. If you have
    indeed asked a homework question, you should consider resubmitting a question more focused on finding
    resources and seeking clarification on confusing issues:
    tell us what you researched so far, what resources you consulted,
    and what you learned, and we are more likely
    to approve your question. Please see this Rules Roundtable
    thread for more information on what makes for
    the kind of homework question we approve. Additionally, if you not sure where to start in terms of finding and understanding
    sources in general, we have a six part series, “Finding and Understanding Sources”,
    which has a wealth of information that may be useful for finding and understanding information for your essay.
    tape in extensions

    cheap wigs After four albums on Epic, LaBelle signed with Philadelphia International Records where she recorded her career
    defining version of “Over the Rainbow” on the album The Spirit’s in It.

    In 1982, she was featured on the Grover Washington duet “The Best Is Yet to Come”, and earned accolades that year for starring in the Broadway musical Your Arms Too Short to Box with
    God. “The Best Is Yet to Come” later earned LaBelle her first Grammy Award
    nomination. cheap wigs

    U Tip Extensions If Kid A, OK Computer, or any of the albums in Radiohead’s impressive discog
    tell us anything it’s that you never know what you’re going to get with these guys.

    They live to keep fans on their toes, and like true artists follow whatever path their muse leads them down, perceptions be damned.
    Whatever they have planned for us this year, their first album since 2007’s
    In Rainbows (let’s forget about King of Limbs, please), we’re interested, and not just
    because it means it’s likely to bring along with it more of Thom Yorke’s dancing U Tip Extensions.

    clip In extensions

  2. I’d must examine with you here. Which isn’t something I often do! I take pleasure in studying a post that can make individuals think. Also, thanks for allowing me to remark!

  3. Hi! I know this is kinda off topic nevertheless I’d figured I’d ask. Would you be interested in trading links or maybe guest writing a blog article or vice-versa? My website covers a lot of the same subjects as yours and I think we could greatly benefit from each other. If you are interested feel free to shoot me an e-mail. I look forward to hearing from you! Wonderful blog by the way!

  4. After study just a few of the blog posts in your website now, and I really like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website list and will probably be checking back soon. Pls take a look at my site as well and let me know what you think.

  5. I’d need to test with you here. Which isn’t something I usually do! I enjoy studying a post that can make people think. Also, thanks for allowing me to comment!

  6. I’m still learning from you, as I’m trying to achieve my goals. I absolutely love reading everything that is posted on your blog.Keep the tips coming. I liked it!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *