Democratic presidential hopefuls (L-R) Senator of Minnesota Amy Klobuchar, Senator of New Jersey Cory Booker, Mayor of South Bend, Indiana, Pete Buttigieg, Senator of Vermont Bernie Sanders, Former Vice President Joe Biden, Senator of Massachusetts Elizabeth Warren, Senator of California Kamala Harris, Tech entrepreneur Andrew Yang, Former Representative of Texas Beto O'Rourke and Former housing secretary Julian Castro participate in the third Democratic primary debate of the 2020 presidential campaign season hosted by ABC News in partnership with Univision at Texas Southern University in Houston, Texas on September 12, 2019. Photo: AFP / Robyn Beck

Contenders for the 2020 Democratic Party presidential nomination, debating among themselves Thursday night in Houston, attacked current President Donald Trump’s trade war as poorly thought out.

With time for little more than sound bites Senator Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota got off the biggest zinger, accusing Trump of “treating our small farmers and workers like poker chips at one of his bankrupt casinos.” As the soybeans pile up in the US Midwest, the US should “go back to the negotiating table,” she said.

“American leadership is needed more than ever,” said Mayor Pete Buttigieg, mayor of South Bend, Indiana. ” There’s a lack of strategy.”

Trump was not alone in getting stamped with the villain label.

“Trade policy in America has been broken for decades,” asserted Senator Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts. Big companies move manufacturing abroad to “save a nickel.”

Warren said if elected she’ll reserve places “at the table” for unions, small farmers, environmentalists and human rights advocates.

She noted that the US has leverage on trade, because “everyone wants access to the American market.”

“I am not a protectionist Democrat,” said Senator Kamala Harris of California. “We need to hold China accountable” – but at the same time partner with China on climate.

Mnuchin comments

US trade negotiators want to make “meaningful progress” in upcoming talks with China, Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin said earlier on Thursday, one day after conciliatory gestures by both sides boosted hopes of an eventual resolution.

Mnuchin said on CNBC he is “cautiously optimistic” about chances for a deal to resolve the conflict, while President Donald Trump hinted at a watering down of his position with the possibility of an interim deal.

Washington and Beijing will first hold talks at the deputy level to ensure senior officials who meet later can advance towards an agreement.

“We don’t want a trip that’s just a series of discussions. We want to make meaningful progress,” Mnuchin said.

However, he again warned that Trump will only accept a good deal, and is willing to raise tariffs if necessary.

Trump told reporters he preferred to seal a complete deal, but that he might be willing to consider an interim agreement.

“I’d rather get the whole deal done,” he said, but noted analysts have been discussing the possibility of an interim deal “meaning we’ll do pieces of it, the easy ones first.”

“There’s no easy or hard, there’s a deal or there’s not a deal. It’s something we would consider I guess,” he said.

There have been positive signs this week in the trade conflict, now entering its second year, as Trump agreed to Beijing’s request to delay one round of tariff increases on $250 billion worth of goods for two weeks, until October 15, after China agreed to spare some US products from its retaliation.

China added Thursday that it was “making enquiries” about buying American farm products including big-ticket items like pork and soybeans, not on its previous list of spared goods.

“It is expected that China will be buying large amounts of our agricultural products!” Trump tweeted early Thursday.

American farmers have borne the brunt of the US-China trade spat, especially after US soy exports collapsed last year, virtually wiping out foreign markets farmers had spent years cultivating.

Trump has previously accused Beijing of backsliding on promises to increase purchases of US farm goods and has offered billions in aid to farms badly damaged in the trade war.

‘Cautiously optimistic’

Senior US and Chinese officials are due to hold preliminary talks later this month, in preparation for meetings in early October led by Mnuchin and US Trade Representative Bob Lighthizer.

Mnuchin said “we clearly didn’t make the progress we wanted to” at the last meeting in Shanghai in late July, but he added: “I’m cautiously optimistic. I take the Chinese in good faith that they want to come here with a deal now.”

But he said Trump “is prepared to keep these tariffs in place. He’s prepared to raise tariffs if we need to raise tariffs.”

Trump’s hardline trade advisor Peter Navarro said on CNN Thursday that the US is focused on addressing “seven acts of economic aggression” by China including “cyber-hacking of our computers to steal our business secrets, intellectual property theft” and “manipulation of the currency.”

However Mnuchin said Hong Kong’s pro-democracy movement “is definitely not on the table,” as “that is an issue for the secretary of state to deal with.”

Millions of people have demonstrated over the last 14 weeks in the biggest challenge to China’s rule of the financial hub since its handover from Britain in 1997.

Hong Kong’s pro-Beijing Chief Executive Carrie Lam warned the United States on Tuesday not to “interfere” with her government’s response.

In the Houston debate, Buttigieg singled out Hong Kong as a situation where “American leadership is needed more than ever.”

‘Eating the tariffs’

Reducing America’s soaring trade deficit with China has long been a principal aim in Trump’s trade battle with Beijing, but so far it has not led to a reduction in the trade imbalance. In 2018, the US goods trade deficit with China was $419.52 billion.

Trump has long viewed deficits as a defeat for the United States, arguing that they amount to stealing – a position rejected by most economists.

Meanwhile the US president maintains that the protracted trade war is damaging China more than the United States, and China is “eating the tariffs.”

The US Treasury has taken in $66 billion in customs duties in the 11 months through August, 73 percent more than in the same period of the prior fiscal year – tariffs paid by American importers.

Experts have warned there are signs the US is also feeling the pinch, with job creation slowing across major industries last month, and manufacturing seeing a decided slowdown.

NAFTA replacement

Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont noted in the Houston debate that he had opposed the North American Free Trade Agreement while Joe Biden, the former vice president who is leading the Democratic pack, favored it.

Earlier in the day, the speaker of the US House of Representatives had said that much work remains before Democrats will be ready to vote on a replacement pact.

“It has to be greatly improved in terms of enforcement,” Nancy Pelosi, a Democrat from California, told reporters. “We think we’re making progress.”

Negotiations with President Donald Trump’s administration to improve guarantees for labor protections for Mexican workers – a key demand of US labor unions – are continuing but there is as yet no text to vote on, she said.

-With reporting by AFP-

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.