Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte is running much of his China diplomacy through his hometown of Davao. Image: Facebook

As Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte passes the midway point of his six-year term, questions are rising fast and furious about whether his government will deliver the Chinese aid and investment-led economic boom it has promised.

While not a single China-backed infrastructure project has broken ground under Duterte, the Philippines’ traditional and more discreet partner Japan has continued to support and finance major infrastructure developments.

Despite China’s highly touted Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), a US$1 trillion program to build infrastructure worldwide, Japan’s infrastructure-related investments ($230 billion) are still much larger than China’s ($155 billion) in Southeast Asia.

In the Philippines, Japan has pledged to spend as much as $43.5 billion on 29 different infrastructure projects. China, in comparison, has only eight projects considered in the pipeline worth a combined $7.4 billion, according to the data from Fitch Solutions.

Even Duterte’s top officials have started to raise critical questions about the non-materialization of China’s multi-billion dollar promises, first made during Duterte’s maiden visit to Beijing in 2016 and then in subsequent top-level bilateral meetings.

Chinese President Xi Jinping (L) and Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte (R) raise a toast during a state banquet at the Malacanang Presidential Palace, Manila, November 20, 2018. Photo: AFP/Pool/Mark R Cristino

On September 26, at an event organized by the Asia Society in New York, Philippine Foreign Secretary Teodoro Locsin said that “debt trap” fears and a trade war-driven outpouring of investment into the Philippines from China are misplaced.

“We signed up this and that [China] agreement, but they hardly materialized,” he said during a panel talk with Asia Society Policy Institute president and former Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd, a noted China expert.

“They hardly materialized, and if you were to compare it with Japanese investments and official assistance, nothing. It seems as if Japan, if there is such a thing as a rising China, apparently there’s a phenomenon…on a rising Japan. And we’re feeling that,” Loscin said.

His comments came amid festering territorial disputes between the Philippines and China in the South China Sea, which have escalated since a suspected Chinese militia vessel rammed and sank a Filipino fishing vessel at the sea’s Reed Bank in June.

National Security Advisor Hermogenes Esperon and Defense Secretary Delfin Lorenzana, meanwhile, have warned about the threat posed by a recent influx of hundreds of thousands of illegal Chinese workers into the Philippines.

Duterte has repeatedly defended China, which has been a staunch supporter of his controversial drug war in international fora. Most recently, Beijing opposed an Iceland-sponsored resolution at the United Nations Human Rights Council, which called for a UN-backed probe into Duterte’s anti-drug campaign.

Even so, China’s promise of an infrastructure investment bonanza, funds that were supposed to drive Duterte’s touted “Build, Build, Build” campaign, has not arrived, putting into doubt the wisdom of his mostly acquiescent policy in the South China Sea.

A Filipino road construction crew on the northern island of Luzon in a file photo. Photo: Twitter

The Filipino leader has repeatedly argued that a pragmatic approach to the sea disputes would be reciprocated with Beijing’s economic largesse.

Ahead of his election in mid-2016, he made it clear that he prefers warmer ties with China, because “We have to talk and what I need from China is not anger. What I need from China is help to develop my country.”

Just months into office, Duterte chose China as his first major state visit in October 2016, where he supposedly secured $24 billion in aid and investments, and declared his will to ‘separate’ from the United States, the Philippines’ mutual defense treaty ally.

Three years later, among China’s ten proposed big-ticket infrastructure projects, only the $60 million Chico River Pump Irrigation Project and another has apparently cleared the preliminary stages of implementation.

Yet even those projects have been hounded by controversies, with critics questioning the financing and repayment terms. Amid an outcry, Duterte recently called for a review of all Chinese projects under consideration.

Other Chinese big-ticket projects such as the Mindanao Railway and the billion-dollar Subic-Clark cargo train project are likewise yet to launch, with the former still at the bidding stage.

Meanwhile, the 29 deals signed during Chinese President Xi Jinping’s visit to the Philippines last November were almost entirely non-binding, leaving little indication of which will and won’t be implemented.

Last year, then-Budget Secretary and current Central Bank Governor Benjamin Diokno complained that China’s leadership should “put pressure on the speed of implementation of all these projects.”

Philippine Finance Secretary Carlos Dominguez III has admitted to several “roadblocks”, including China’s initial insistence on using renminbi in aid disbursement, heavy reliance on Chinese workers and managers, and an unwillingness to co-finance projects with other lenders such as Japan and the Asian Development Bank (ADB).

So far, China’s infrastructure development aid has been limited to two bridges across the Pasig River, totaling about $198.8 million. Critics, however, claim that the projects were either unnecessary or ended up benefiting only Chinese contractors.

Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte (L) shakes hands with Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe in Manila, November 13, 2017. Photo: The Yomiuri Shimbun via AFP

Japan, still the Philippines’ leading source of development aid, has meanwhile continues to bankroll several major infrastructure projects, including the multi-billion dollar Metro-Manila subway metro project, the country’s first, and the North-South Commuter Railway project, which will connect industrialized regions in the northern island of Luzon.

More Japanese infrastructure funds could be on the way after the European Union and Japan signed an infrastructure development deal on September 27 to coordinate transport, energy and digital projects linking Europe and Asia as an alternative to China’s BRI. The new EU-Japan initiative will be backed initially with $65.5 billion in funds.

Philippine Presidential Spokesman Salvador Panelo has been quick to downplay concerns over the delay in Chinese investments, saying the problem is as much local as Chinese.

In response to recent queries, the spokesman said, “You know why? One time I talked to Ambassador Zhao [Jianhua] and he told me, ‘Your government requirements are stringent. There are a lot of processes.’”

“We have no problem on our side, they said. We are always okay, it’s you that are slow, that’s what it seemed to be,” China’s top envoy to the Philippines reportedly told Panelo.

Asia Times Financial is now live. Linking accurate news, insightful analysis and local knowledge with the ATF China Bond 50 Index, the world's first benchmark cross sector Chinese Bond Indices. Read ATF now. 

Join the Conversation

2 Comments

  1. Cheap Swimsuits
    Saline inplants is made up of salt water. Both inplants have
    their pros and cons. That is why a serious talk with a surgeon is in order so you can mutually
    arrive at the best option for you.. MacTaggert, seeking Xavier’s advice on mutation, takes him and Raven to the CIA, where they
    convince Director McCone that mutants exist and Shaw is a threat.
    Another CIA officer sponsors the mutants and invites
    them to the secret “Division X” facility. MacTaggert
    and Xavier find Shaw as Lehnsherr is attacking him, and rescue Lehnsherr from drowning, while Shaw escapes.

    cheap swimwear The Beaches of LefkasThe town beach at Vassiliki is made of white pebbles.
    This is true of many beaches on Lefkas. There was a small beach just outside
    of our hotel in Vassiliki which was perfect but was still made of
    large white pebbles. I have been to all 59 of our state’s covered bridges and have
    kissed girls in 6 of them. Then they ran out, so there a big missing patch on the
    bottom floor that they covered with an outdoor rubber mat.
    It always fun coming in with wet shoes trying to climb the stairs with an armload
    of groceries and not busting your ass.. cheap swimwear

    Cheap Swimsuits I also thought the episodes were actually kinda dark, but in a very human way.
    The first four didn end with things back to the way they were.
    They remained broken, but the people who were dealing with it adapted.

    It crazy, like. I could go out and run 16 miles any weekend
    of the year, no issue! Racing a half marathon? psh lol yeah I see you guys back at the track in like.
    A month haha.If the half for you was a big distance achievement
    or pace/effort achievement, then yup, it can take a long ass time to finally feel “back”!
    Glad you finally feel ready to get back into things!sayaveronica 12 points submitted 1 day agoDoes anybody else read stuff about how women can ride/run/whatever as fast as men can and feel like it a challenge?

    lol. Cheap Swimsuits

    one piece swimsuits We believe that the market does not
    realize the full potential of what Wilsons as well as two other acquisitions means for G III.
    A recent move by GIII suggests that they are taking Wilsons
    another step. The company noted in their last earnings call that they are interested in more full price retail as well.
    one piece swimsuits

    Cheap Swimsuits On the day of the Sports Meet, Futaba
    behaves ravenously in a game of piggyback, much to
    the lament of Hitoha and Mitsuba. Later in class, Yabe
    collapses with a fever, but when Hitoha goes to check on him,
    Sakiko is setting up some kind of ritual, which makes things awkward for Hitoha.
    During class, Miku tries to make Mitsuba jealous of her, but only ends up embarrassing herself.
    Cheap Swimsuits

    wholesale bikinis Altuzarra’s gingham suiting; the Christian Dior
    frock coats (admittedly, the latter were worn over board shorts, but still).
    “I think it’s changing,” Ms. Kreitzman said. I
    spent six months in the Kabul area with the US military in 2006 2007.
    My unit created a simple charity in which we asked our family and friends back home to donate school supplies.
    We stockpiled the supplies, and about once a month
    we would bring the donated items to a local school. wholesale bikinis

    Bathing Suits I from Canada but live in the UK. I used to use a local Sim
    whenever I went to visit, but it still was like $50 each trip
    for minimal usage (500mb data). My plan now just
    allows me to use it there so I don need the extra
    Sim. I have enjoyed my breastfeeding relationships with both
    of my kids, and while C weaned at nearly 3
    years old, L and I are still going strong. Breastfeeding was difficult for me during the first several months after
    birth. I struggled with each of them, in different ways,
    and until they were at least six months old, I can honestly say
    I didn love it.. Bathing Suits

    cheap swimwear Mine was pretty freakin fast for numero one (and
    also very scary). I guess I should prepare
    in either case that I might give birth again on our kitchen floor.
    Heck, my mom gave birth to me in an elevator and my sister in the
    back of a pizza van (true story). cheap swimwear

    one piece swimsuits Emmy Rossum, star of the Showtime series “Shameless,” told The Hollywood Reporter’s
    Emmy contender roundtables that she was once
    required to come to a director’s office in her bikini.

    “My agent called me and was like, ‘I’m so embarrassed to make this call, but there’s a big movie and they’re going to offer it to you. They really love your work on the show one piece swimsuits.

  2. Zithromax Iron Interaction [url=http://sildenafdosage.com]viagra online prescription[/url] Amoxicillin Ok To Be In Sun Propecia Ivf Viagra Noprescription

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *