People wear masks in support of KPK investigator Novel Baswedan's face to show support after he suffered a debilitating acid attack, Jakarta, February 22, 2018. Photo: Andalou Agency via AFP Forum/Eko Siswono Toyudho

Indonesian President Joko Widodo will enter his second term next month under a black cloud over his support for a series of amendments to the 2002 Anti-Corruption Law. The revisions, passed on September 17, will undermine the effectiveness of the country’s independent graft-fighting agency and its endless war against official malfeasance.

Indonesia’s House of Representatives (DPR) has taken aim at the much-admired Anti-Corruption Commission (KPK) on several previous occasions but this time critics fear the worst with glaring headlines variously calling it the “death knell” and “the end.”

It is not a good start for Widodo, who will be officially inaugurated on October 20, three weeks after the current Parliament completes its five-year term and is replaced by the newly expanded 575-seat House, which was elected in April.

The law revision is not the only concern. The head of the new five-strong commission, which takes over in December, is former South Sumatra police chief Firli Bahuri, whom the KPK has previously accused of committing “gross ethical violations” when he was a commission investigator in 2017-18.

Reflecting a general lack of trust in Parliament, outgoing KPK chairman Agus Raharjo had warned Widodo that any weakening of the corruption eradication effort would send the wrong message to potential investors and hit already flagging economic growth.

KPK chairman Agus Raharjo with the KPK’s logo in the background in a file photo. Photo: Twitter

Transparency International (TI), a corruption watchdog, found in a 2017 survey that bribes accounted for 10% of Indonesia’s production costs, with about 17% of the participants blaming the failure of their businesses on competitors paying officials for favors.

Saying they had been blindsided by the revival of the long-stalled revision, Raharjo and two other commissioners threatened to hand back their mandates to the president, but later elected to stay on for the remaining three months before their terms end.

The KPK questions why it has so far never been consulted by Parliament’s legal commission, or why the president’s promise to review the work of the country’s law enforcement agencies has only focused on the commission when the Attorney General’s Office (AGO) and the police have more to answer.

Even though the bill was not on the official legislation agenda, as it should have been, the president was the only figure who could have stopped its passage. Instead, he gave Parliament the go-ahead to rush through the legislation in the short time it has left.

“Now the decision is entirely in the hands of Jokowi (Widodo),” Tempo magazine said in a caustic editorial days before it passed. “He could save the KPK, or he could not. If he makes the second choice, we must dig a grave for the KPK – and also one for our trust in the president.”

Indonesian President Joko Widodo waves at an ASEAN summit event at Clark, Pampanga, northern Philippines November 12, 2017. Photo: Twitter

TI and more than 2,300 lecturers from 33 universities across Indonesia had rejected the draft law, with TI calling the KPK a “vital pillar” and noting that Indonesia has languished in the bottom third of its Corruption Perceptions Index for years.

Among a slew of other provisions, the amendment nullifies the independence of the KPK’s 1,000 employees, bringing them under the rules-laden umbrella of the civil service, and, more crucially, requires a supposedly independent supervisory board to sign off on all wiretaps, searches and seizures.

The blatant motive behind the wiretap revision is clear. Since it was formed in 2003, the KPK has used wiretaps to successfully bring graft convictions against 255 parliamentarians, six political party leaders and 27 ministers and state agency heads.

Politicians from Widodo’s ruling Indonesian Democratic Party for Struggle (PDI-P) and its coalition partner Golkar Party, the two biggest parties and the main backers of the amendments, have the highest number of offenders jailed for stealing from the public purse.

The revised legislation also stipulates that KPK investigators can only be recruited from the national police, despite a 2015 Constitution Court ruling which reinforced the KPK’s authority to appoint its own investigators from other civilian agencies.

Critics say police are unlikely to investigate their own colleagues in a force regarded as one of Indonesia’s most corrupt institutions, pointing to its failure to find the culprits behind the 2017 acid attack against KPK investigator Novel Baswedan.

Analysts point to the need for police to focus on other crimes and note that those who have been recruited in the past to the KPK investigation team often stay for only a short period before a promotion calls them back to service.

Moreover, the revised law compels the KPK to coordinate with the AGO, another agency with a checkered history, before it can proceed with a prosecution, and can only issue travel bans or block accounts during the investigation phase of a case.

Widodo did supposedly oppose the revision allowing for only police investigators, and claimed to be against another clause which requires the KPK to consult with the AGO on sentencing. He also said he wants the KPK to continue monitoring the wealth reports of government officials.

What the KPK will be able to do is terminate an investigation that has not been resolved within a year – something that will come as a relief to Joost Lino, former head of state-owned port operator PT Pelabuhan II, who has been a graft suspect for nearly four years.

Lino is one of several senior officials indicted for corruption, all based on business decisions which are alleged to have caused losses to the state – a questionable criteria for graft charges when there is no evidence of personal enrichment.

Stacks of Indonesian rupiah notes. Photo: AFP / Bay Ismoyo

While many of the provisions are common practice in other countries, former KPK commissioners and other activists simply don’t believe that the integrity and the secrecy of the commission’s process can be protected when Indonesia’s rule of law is not nearly as strong.

In any event, most other anti-corruption bodies are solely responsible for deciding who and when to wiretap, the main weapon in corruption inquiries, while their supervisors map out strategy, conduct audits and field public complaints.

“The great strength of the KPK, which shocked the Indonesian elite, is that it has been able to keep that high level of integrity,” says one foreign anti-corruption expert. “There was a perception when it was formed that it would be as leaky as any other system.”

Independent analysts are puzzled why the president bought into the self-serving argument that the KPK is in need of disciplining when the only complaints about the work of the commission come from those who have been its main targets.

“The president has been misled by politicians,” says one retired KPK commissioner, who suspects Widodo’s support for the revised law may be in exchange for proposed changes to the leadership structure of the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR), the nation’s highest legislative branch.

For all of the claims that it is too powerful, it is difficult to argue with the KPK’s almost perfect conviction record, a consistent 80% approval rating from the public and an average of 7,000 corruption tip-offs a year to its 24-hour secure hotline.

Widodo has complained in meetings that the KPK’s aggressive approach to its work is making officials afraid to make decisions and slowing down governance. Instead of focusing on investigations and prosecutions, he wants the KPK to spend more time on prevention.

Concentrating on that, the president believes, will help to systematically shut off the inventive ways in which politicians, jurists and state officials, who all fall under the KPK’s purview, can continue to plunder trillions of rupiah of public funds.

For now, however, he is a voice in the wilderness because of the secretive nature of the legislative process. When Widodo and his staff opened one newspaper this week leading on the KPK controversy, they were greeted by a black front page headlined: “Under the blanket of darkness.”

Editor’s Note: This story was revised from a previous version to reflect the September 17 passage by Parliament of amendments to the 2002 Anti-Corruption Law.

Asia Times Financial is now live. Linking accurate news, insightful analysis and local knowledge with the ATF China Bond 50 Index, the world's first benchmark cross sector Chinese Bond Indices. Read ATF now. 

Join the Conversation

17 Comments

  1. I do not even know the way I finished up right here, however I assumed this
    put up was great. I do not understand who you are
    but certainly you are going to a famous blogger in the
    event you aren’t already. Cheers!

  2. Hmm it appears like your site ate my first comment (it was super long) so
    I guess I’ll just sum it up what I submitted and say, I’m thoroughly
    enjoying your blog. I as well am an aspiring blog writer
    but I’m still new to the whole thing. Do you have any recommendations for newbie
    blog writers? I’d really appreciate it.

  3. I do believe all the ideas you’ve presented for
    your post. They’re very convincing and will definitely work.
    Nonetheless, the posts are very brief for beginners. May just you please extend them a bit from
    next time? Thanks for the post.

  4. I’ve learn a few just right stuff here. Certainly value bookmarking for revisiting.
    I surprise how so much attempt you put to create such a wonderful
    informative site.

  5. Yesterday, while I was at work, my sister stole my apple
    ipad and tested to see if it can survive a twenty five foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My iPad is now broken and she has 83 views.
    I know this is entirely off topic but I had to share it with someone!

  6. Nuestro cometido es que usted se despreocupe de la reparación de su Aire Acondicionado Sampo y su factura desde el momento que se pone en contacto con nosotros. Perderá tiempo y dinero ya que ese aparato y su reparación serán nuevos para él. Por ello, confíe en nosotros, somos TÉCNICOS ESPECIALISTAS EN Aire Acondicionado Sampo desde hace 24 anos, conocemos la tecnología y estamos a la última de las innovaciones de Sampo. Nuestro SERVICIO TÉCNICO ESPECIALIZADO EN Aire Acondicionado Sampo garantiza una solución completa a su problema: Diagnosticamos su avería y la solucionamos. Aquellos que estén interesados se pondrán en contacto contigo para pasarte un presupuesto.

  7. Existe una oficina en la Capital, Santiago de Chile, que contrata servicios técnicos externos, es decir, ellos no tienen técnicos propios, todo se demora además una semana el arreglo estando a 120 kilómetros de distancia. Hace 10 años estuve en las instalaciones de HAIER en China, por mi condición de responsable de la posventa de esta Marca en España, en unión del e resto de responsables de todos los países europeos. Por esa razón, puedes tener problemas con esa marca respecto a recambios y Servicio Técnico.

  8. Si me equivoco y quien escribió el mensaje 535 es el Subdirector del Departamento Comercial de Citroën, éste no tendrá ningún problema en utilizar sus contactos con km77 para que el sitio web medie en su contacto y establezca las auténticas identidades de ambos. Es el coche más seguro, el más cómodo, el más exclusivo y el que menos posibilidades de robarlo.

  9. Nuestros técnicos especialistas están en constante aprendizaje, por lo que están totalmente capacitados para llevar a cabo la reparación de cualquier nevera congelador Siemens. Después de explicarnos su problema, nuestro técnico más adecuado para su tipo de avería irá a su hogar el mismo día para solucionarselo. Una interminable lista de electrodomésticos para hacerles la vida mucho más snecilla y cómoda.

  10. Empresa dedicada a la reparación e instalación de gas, calefacciòn y aire acondicionado. Después de perder mucho tiempo navegando por la complicada web de asistencia de Sony VAIO, dí con un un número de teléfono. Inocente de mí, al no haber pasado dos años de la compra, llamé al nº de teléfono para equipos en garantía. Ahí, un ordenador me dijo al introducir el nº de serie que ya no lo está, que es sólo de un año: primera ilegalidad: en España la garantía de los productos electrónicos es de 2 años por ley. Creo que no compro nada SONY , en mi vida y; !Ojo a navegantes¡si compras tecnología desde luego piensa en el servicio de postventa, no en SONY.

  11. Sevilla cuenta con el casco viejo mas grande de Espana, y entre los mas extensos de Europa, atrayendo sus monumentos a abundantes turistas nacionales e internacionales, lo que la convierte en la tercera capital mas visitada de Espana, por detras unicamente de Barcelona y Madrid. Nuestros clientes del servicio son nuestra mejor publicidad y nos confieren credito en el alquiler de vehiculos en Alicante aeropuerto.

  12. Servicio Técnico electrodomésticos Madrid, pionero en reparaciones de electrodomésticos en Madrid , con más 24 años reparando todo tipo de electrodomésticos, ponemos a su disposición a nuestro personal técnico para resolverle cualquier tipo de incidencia que pueda presentar el aparato, el mismo día de su aviso.

  13. PERO, a partir del sexto mes, es al consumidor al que le corresponde probar (mediante un informe de un técnico perito, por ejemplo) que el defecto era de origen y ya existía en el momento de la entrega del producto. Ah, y además eso de que te lo cambian por otro” ya está pasando de moda, ahora lo que mola” es que te reparen el producto: compras un portátil de 1500 euros, por poner un ejemplo; a los 15 días se te escoña y lo envías a la servicio ténico.

  14. Empresa prestadora de Servicios Jurídicos Pre pagados con Excelente proyección profesional, requiere Abogado Especialista en Derecho Laboral Comercial con Experiencia mínima de 3 años en el área, con alta responsabilidad y ética, excelente presentación personal. Empresa vinculada en el sector salud, solicita técnicos sistemas que se encuentren en etapa productiva, con un salario del 75 sobre el smlv más prestaciones sociales, con disponibilidad de tiempo completo.

  15. HERCA S.L es una empresa enmarcada en el sector industrial, dentro del ámbito del mecanizado, rectificado, fresado y roscado. En Mecanizados velamos por la calidad de vida de nuestro equipo humano, generando puestos de trabajo equilibrados, fomentando la profesionalidad y motivando la implicación y el espíritu de equipo dentro de la organización. Mecanizados, proyectos, soldadura especial, fabricación y reparaciones de maquinaria, repuestos.

  16. Mecanizado de todo tipo de piezas metálicas y no metálicas en máquinas de control numérico, tanto trabajos seriados como unitarios. También por este motivo, la CNC de 5 ejes actual representa la base para el procesamiento diario de diferentes materiales. Otra mejora que se persigue con este innovador tipo de máquinas es aumentar el volumen en el cual el husillo puede actuar, para poder mecanizar piezas grandes.

  17. Para cualquier otro tipo de sector en el que se precise requiera la fabricación de elementos mediante mecanización en serie y decoletaje industrial, Floper puede ayudarte. 45. Pasador roscado mecanizado por decoletaje en acero © Kuzu, S.L. Talleres De Decoletaje La Precision, S.L.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *