The Indian Army's Special Forces are deployed in counterinsurgency operations in Jammu and Kashmir. Photo: Wikipedia

An attack on a military camp in September 2016 shocked Indians and their government. Militants from Pakistan infiltrated across the Line of Control, which divides Kashmir between the two nations, and attacked a brigade camp in the Uri sector.

India promptly retaliated with cross-border raids attacking “terrorist launch pads” at five places. The Narendra Modi government proudly described the responses as “surgical strikes” by Indian Special Forces.

But the efforts unintentionally highlighted the limited nature of Special Forces capabilities – and especially the fact that Special Forces units are divided under various service heads, ensuring that there is very little coordination among units attached to the army, navy and air force. This forced the Prime Minister’s Office to initiate urgent discussions with India’s top military commanders.

Some changes were made, and by now enough time has elapsed for some tentative professional opinions to emerge about their efficacy. Unfortunately, the consensus verdict so far appears to be: Same old same old.

History: Kennedy and Nehru

India’s military was largely structured as the British created it during its colonial rule. In more recent decades, however, British special forces have seen a significant restructuring with a major general appointed as “director general (special forces)” who is also part of the prime minister’s crisis management committee. This allows a single point of professional advice from the Special Forces to the highest political authorities in the UK.

Independent India’s special forces were born in the the aftermath of the humiliating defeat in the border war with China in 1962. The US had already started arming Tibetan militias to try and stem the Chinese influence in the region.

Discussions between President John F Kennedy and Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru led to cooperation between the Central Intelligence Agency and India’s Intelligence Bureau. This led to the birth of a secret force, made up of Tibetans with Indian Army officers, called the Special Frontier Force or 2-2 Special Forces (2-2 SF).

However, while the 2-2 SF focused solely on China, there was a need for a dedicated special forces unit following the 1965 war with Pakistan. The first unit, raised as the 9th battalion of the Parachute Regiment as a “para-commando” unit, was set up in 1967. By 1968, a second unit was raised and christened as 10 Para-Commando.

Both these units would perform exceedingly well in the 1971 war with Pakistan that led to the birth of Bangladesh. By 1980, an existing parachute battalion, 1 Para, was also converted to a special forces role. In 1990 all the existing “para-commando” battalions were re-christened “Special Forces.”

In 1987, as India ventured into the Sri Lankan civil war, the navy decided to create its special forces capability. It sent off two officers to attend the US Navy SEALs basic course. Lieutenant Arvind Singh aced the course and returned to India to create the Indian Marine Special Forces. In a few years this was renamed the Marine Commando Force (MARCOS).

By 2003, the Indian Air Force had started plans to raise its special forces. Named after a mythical bird, the Garuds were primarily for search and rescue missions.

Alas, by the middle of 2006, India’s multiple special forces were disjointed, expanding rapidly and competing for limited resources, while responding to multiple commands.

Restructuring special forces

Just weeks before the results of India’s general elections were announced, the Modi government announced that Major General A K Dhingra would be the first commander of a newly created Special Operations Division. The SOD is India’s version of the United States Special Operations Command, based at McDill Air Force Base in Florida.

The SOD is the outcome of one of the “reform” efforts initiated soon after the Kashmir attack. Lieutenant General Hardev Singh Lidder, commissioned into the first army special forces unit that was set up in 1967-68, rose through the service and retired as an army commander. He was tasked to prepare a paper on setting up a special forces command.

However, Lidder’s proposal met with resistance in the Ministry of Defense with civilian bureaucrats raising doubts about the concept. The civilians object to giving that much power to the military. “Frankly, I am not sure if they are interested in getting the kind of capabilities that we need,” Lidder told Asia Times.

Faced with resistance to the idea of creating a US-style command structure, everyone settled for a compromise called the Special Forces Division. While a normal division has about 9000 fighting troops, this one is supposed to be significantly smaller.

“This creates some very real problems,” said Lieutenant General Prakash Katoch, a former special forces veteran who wrote three key papers on restructuring India’s special operations capabilities. “Basically we should have started with two or three battalions, and that would form part of the core special operations capability,” he said.

SOD is also being placed under the chief of integrated defense staff (CIDS), a stop-gap arrangement that was created after the Kargil war, but has continued since then because a proposal regarding a chief of defense staff was never cleared.

Politicians don’t want a post called chief of defense staff, which would be filled by the most senior military officer, because they fear the post would assume too much power, so they’ve stuck with CIDS, a post held by a junior general.

The result of the “reforms”: Each current Special Forces unit remains part of its respective service and the units have no cross-functional capability. They procure weapons separately, don’t operate together and respond to particular needs of their individual services rather than to national objectives. All planning, training, tasking and equipping is done separately.

While India’s military planners primarily focus on traditional rival Pakistan, they fail to appreciate that China poses a much bigger threat with a rapidly modernizing military. “We know that the Chinese have significant special operations capabilities that are integrated with their cyber and intelligence apparatus. We have not even started integrating our three services and the division has not been envisaged as one,” Katoch said.

In 2003, when US General Stanley McChrystal took over the Joint Special Operations Command (JSOC) in Iraq, he realized that the National Security Agency (NSA) was barely 500 meters away from his JSOC teams, but they never worked together. In his book Team of Teams he details how they created joint teams to start inflicting heavy losses on Iraqi insurgents.

“The future of warfare has changed and we will need more special forces for sub-conventional capabilities. Unless we look at a holistic structure, what we are creating is unlikely to be useful, even though it will address some issues of coordinating the three services better,” Katoch said.

Sources in the Ministry of Defense are also skeptical of the move on other grounds. “The government couldn’t have picked a better man to head the Division than Major General Dhingra,” a senior military official said. “However, he is likely to retire next year. This will create a problem of continuity.”

“They have also decided to set up the headquarters in Agra, while they should have been in Delhi,” the senior official said. “Special Forces work best when they have access to the highest political and military hierarchy. By shifting them to Agra, they will become impotent as a force.”

So far, then, India’s attempt at re-organizing its military capabilities seems to have brought more of the same.

Asia Times Financial is now live. Linking accurate news, insightful analysis and local knowledge with the ATF China Bond 50 Index, the world's first benchmark cross sector Chinese Bond Indices. Read ATF now. 

Join the Conversation

1146 Comments

  1. I haven?¦t checked in here for a while since I thought it was getting boring, but the last several posts are great quality so I guess I?¦ll add you back to my daily bloglist. You deserve it my friend 🙂

  2. You could definitely see your expertise within the work you write. The world hopes for more passionate writers like you who aren’t afraid to say how they believe. All the time go after your heart. “In America, through pressure of conformity, there is freedom of choice, but nothing to choose from.” by Peter Ustinov.

  3. I loved as much as you’ll receive carried out right here. The sketch is attractive, your authored subject matter stylish. nonetheless, you command get got an impatience over that you wish be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come more formerly again as exactly the same nearly a lot often inside case you shield this hike.

  4. Ya no hay más, pues yo no compraría nunca una marca blanca (ROMMER), ni por su calidad medianilla”, ni por su origen (italiano del montón) ni por su Servicio Técnico, que hasta hace 4 años era como si no lo tuviera, y que actualmente no puede haber ido a peor. Al intentar informarme sobre el producto en internet, me encuentro que ni siquiera en la WEB de HAIER, está reconocido tal modelo. Espero no haber errado en la compra y poder tener buen servicio (MEJOR NO NECESITARLO EL SERVICIO TECNICO). Es posible que sea un modelo reciente, y como HAIER tiene cientos de frigoríficos distintos, puede ser una remesa de hace poco.

  5. Hi , I do believe this is an excellent blog. I stumbled upon it on Yahoo , i will come back once again. Money and freedom is the best way to change, may you be rich and help other people.

  6. Hello, Neat post. There is an issue together with your web site in web explorer, might test this… IE still is the market leader and a good element of folks will pass over your excellent writing due to this problem.

  7. Good site! I truly love how it is easy on my eyes it is. I am wondering how I might be notified when a new post has been made. I’ve subscribed to your RSS which may do the trick? Have a great day!

  8. Hi! Would you mind if I share your blog with my twitter group? There’s a lot of people that I think would really appreciate your content. Please let me know. Thank you

  9. La marca AMAÑA la importó en España FRIGICOLL, un importante importadoir de aparatos de refrigeración que hizo (y hace) sus pinitos en el campo de los electrodomésticos que en su día (de eso hace mucho tiempo) fueron punteros pero que hoy en día han sido totalmente superador en todos los aspectos por las marcas citadas y otras europeas. El grupo BSH (BOSCH SIEMENS hausgerate Gmbh) es alemán y tiene fabricación y distribución en España.

  10. Cuando me refiero al filtro super crema es al que lleva la Minimoka CM-1 22 que es para capsulas tipo ESE, con ese si hago un cafe echando cafe para 1 taza sale con crema y en cambio con el cacillo que viene para las dos tazas y que según el manual es para el cafe molido independientemente si hace una taza dos sólo depende de la cantidad de café que le eches, con ese cacillo (filtro no sale nada de crema) y antes hacia el café con suficiente crema.

  11. La alusión al Servicio Técnico es porque quienes tenéis máquinas más antiguas, a veces, acudís a Servicios que ya no lo son de la marca y os encontráis con todo tipo de respuestas. Y si hemos interpretado bien a qué pieza te referías, está disponible en nuestro almacén y, por tanto, cualquier servicio técnico oficial te la puede y debe suministrar a la mayor brevedad. En la capital Pamplona puedes encontrar un Servicio técnico en la calle SANGUESA 38, su nombre es Telenavarra. Hola, hace mucho tiempo que tengo en casa una minimoka M-3 3 y me gustaría saber donde hay un servicio técnico, para poder comprar unos recambios y también me gustaría saber si el manual de instrucciones de esta maquina lo puedo encontrar en la web en algún lugar.

  12. En caso que no encuentre la marca de su electrodoméstico en esta lista no dude en llamarnos al .278.94.37 enviarnos un correo a través de nuestro formulario de contacto (1). Técnicos especialistas en la reparación de lavadoras Rommer, lavavajillas Rommer, frigoríficos Rommer, cocinas Rommer, hornos Rommer y vitrocerámicas Rommer. En el supuesto de que haya que llevarse su aparato Rommer averiado, disponemos de talleres especializados y preparados para llevar a cabo una reparación exhaustiva y precisa del mismo.

  13. Attractive section of content. I just stumbled upon your site and in accession capital to assert that I get actually enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I will be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently quickly.

  14. Excellent read, I just passed this onto a friend who was doing a little research on that. And he just bought me lunch since I found it for him smile So let me rephrase that: Thank you for lunch! “High living and high thinking are poles apart.” by B. J. Gupta.

  15. Ponemos a disposición de nuestros clientes un presupuesto gratuito, sin compromiso y totalmente ajustable al bolsillo de cada cliente, porque no todos son iguales, por lo que ello supone una tarea difícil que es la de complacer a todos aquellos que confíen en nuestro servicio tecnico para frigorificos. No pierda el tiempo ni el dinero con otras empresas, le aseguramos y le damos total garantía de que sea el electrodoméstico que sea, la marca modelo del que disponga, tenemos a una amplia gama de profesionales especializados en todos y en cada uno de los diferentes áreas en las que le ofrecemos nuestro servicio tecnico de neveras.

  16. whoah this weblog is wonderful i love studying your posts. Stay up the good paintings! You recognize, a lot of individuals are hunting around for this info, you can aid them greatly.

  17. Does your site have a contact page? I’m having trouble locating it but, I’d like to send you an e-mail. I’ve got some recommendations for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great blog and I look forward to seeing it improve over time.

  18. PIEZAS TORNEADAS, ARANDELAS DE AJUSTE. Para obtener mayores niveles de precisión, los dibujos se transformarán cuidadosamente en imágenes computarizadas que más tarde serán producidas por la maquinaria CNC más puntera. La tipología de materiales con los que trabajamos es diversa, desde calidades de aluminio y aceros tratados, hasta plásticos técnicos y resinas.

  19. Antes de la revolución industrial este tipo de procesos se hacían a mano en talleres de madera, de forja cerámicos, entre otros, y no se conocían como mecanizado. Así pues hablamos de centros de mecanizado de 5 ejes y tornos multifunción, que permiten obtener una pieza compleja, totalmente terminada, partiendo de un tocho de una barra de metal y todo ello en un único amarre.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *