Brunei's Sultan Hassanal Bolkiah salutes during National Day celebrations in Bandar Seri Begawan, Brunei, February 24, 2018. Photo: Twitter

There has been no shortage of invective directed at Brunei’s decision this month to introduce far more tyrannical punishments under its Islamic legal system. Sharia was first introduced in 2014 by Brunei’s absolute monarch, Sultan Hassanal Bolkiah, but has now been augmented in its final phase so that homosexual sex between men and adultery can be punished by death, including by stoning, while lesbians will receive lashes and thieves can have their limbs cut off. It might appear an archaic word, but these archaic punishments can only be described as barbaric.

Within the many diatribes, a conspicuous phrase has popped up again and again: to “burnish one’s Islamic credentials.” The Guardian, in a report published on April 3, stated that “analysts say [Sultan Bolkiah] is seeking to burnish his Islamic credentials and shore up support among the country’s conservatives due to the waning fortunes of the oil-dependent economy, which has been ravaged by recession in recent years.” A report from Agence France-Presse, published a day earlier, reads that the sultan “is seeking to burnish his Islamic credentials among conservative supporters.” Shinta Eka Puspasari, an analyst at Concord Consulting Jakarta, only slightly went off script when he stated that the new law is designed to “strengthen Bolkiah’s Islamic credentials and popularity among his people.”

A swift search on Google finds that this bon mot has been used at least a dozen times to describe government policy in Malaysia (by both the former and new government) and Indonesia, while it’s more frequently used to refer to politics in Saudi Arabia and the wider Middle East – pretty much every Muslim-majority nation, actually, and even those with vocal Muslim minorities. It also crops up in academic works, such as Eric O Hanson’s Religion and Politics in the International System Today, and at least three dozen other books.

I have used this phrase myself on occasion, though now looking back it seems that I never really gave much thought as to why. Quite clearly, it’s a rather lissom phrase to describe a politician who adopts a far more extreme position on religious matters in order to win support from the public – indeed, it denotes both opportunism and populism at the same time. But its meaning is more profound. The word “burnish” is rather obvious, meaning to polish something to make it shinier: shiny because of the politician’s apparent dulled image on Islamic issues, and shiny because his policies are appealing to the public at large.

Now comes the more tricky part: What is actually meant by “Islamic credentials”? In almost all the contexts this phrase is used in, it denotes the imposition of a far more radical notion of Islamic law on to a society. However, the purveyor of this phrase often enters the realm of euphemism. Both The Guardian and AFP reports, as well as other articles on the same issue, contend that Brunei’s sultan is ramping up sharia punishments to appease “conservatives” or his “conservative supporters.” A Southeast Asia Globe report states that “the move marks a transition to a more conservative form of Islam in the country.”

But is “conservative” a fair adjective for someone who supports the stoning to death of homosexuals and adulterers? Doesn’t it appear that “conservative” is being used not as an actual indicator of a position but as a euphemism – or as a lazy qualifier? A journalist is supposed to be a caretaker of semantics, after all, so isn’t it more fair to say that rather than being a “conservative” the person who supports stoning to death is actually a “radical” or “extremist” – or, in the case of religion, a “literalist”?

For some context, a Pew Research Center survey conducted in 2013 found that 72% of Indonesian and 86% of Malaysian respondents said they wanted sharia to be the national law (which it isn’t) and, of those, some 60% from Malaysia and 48% from Indonesia thought stoning to death was an appropriate penalty for adultery.

What one finds, then, is that whenever “to burnish one’s Islamic credentials” is employed, it is used to denote an extreme position on Islamic law, typically to do with sexual behavior or free speech. It’s almost never used in more trifling contexts. Indeed, Brunei’s sultan didn’t “burnish his Islamic credentials” by investing more money into Islamic banking or, in reverse, by cracking down on riba (usury). Nor did he do so by taking a strong, vocal stance against how China is locking up members of its Muslim minority in re-education camps by the hundreds of thousands, which has sparked concerns about ethnic cleansing. (We’ve hardly heard a peep from Islamist politicians in Asia about it.) “This selective implementation of the most draconian aspects of the Sharia, particularly upon an already oppressed and repressed queer Malay-Muslim minority[,] only shows that Brunei is closer to ISIS than to the Prophet,” writes Azfar B Anwar, an Islamic studies and history student at the University of Oxford.

But pay attention to the deeper meaning of the phrase. It’s supposed to denote a populist measure, usually one introduced to distract public attention away from some other problem – economic stagnation in Brunei’s case. Or, a corollary, as a populist measure supposed to win a politician support from the majority of the public. Yet in both senses it would indicate that such measures are popular, perhaps even with a significant section of society. Indeed, would Brunei’s sultan have introduced a law for the stoning to death of homosexuals unless he knew it would chime well with the majority of the country? If all of this is merely an attempt by a politician to “burnish” his appeal vis-à-vis his public perception, even his opportunism is a sign that such measures are desired by the public.

“On the ground, young Bruneians say they are less scared of being prosecuted under the new laws than of how they might embolden religious conservatives, and justify acts of hate against them,” reported The Guardian on April 6. The article also featured an interview with a young homosexual man who said: “I am not really scared about the law, but I am scared about the people.… The implementation gives a lot of conservative people who are very homophobic a lot of power. It is more dangerous for people like me to go out now.”

So what are we left to think? For most commentators, the fallout of Brunei’s new policies has been laid squarely at the feet of the sultan (including by some celebrities who can only think of boycotting the luxury hotels he owns as a way to respond). But if the sultan has done this for populist and opportunistic reasons, as almost all analysts say he has, shouldn’t some of the fault be shared by the Brunei public itself, who the sultan clearly thinks support the measures? Isn’t it more a reflection on Brunei society than the sultan himself?

What “to burnish one’s Islamic credentials” reveals, then, is not just a populist, opportunistic move by a politician, but also a desire for the significant section of the population for such extreme laws. Take it one step further: If one accepts that stoning to death for homosexuality is a populist policy introduced by sultan, then one must ask why it has only now been introduced. Indeed, up until now, Bolkiah actually resisted the introduction of a tyrannical law that is apparently popular with the majority of the public (until, of course, it became politically convenient for him to do so).

Asia Times Financial is now live. Linking accurate news, insightful analysis and local knowledge with the ATF China Bond 50 Index, the world's first benchmark cross sector Chinese Bond Indices. Read ATF now. 

Join the Conversation

22 Comments

  1. It is indeed my belief that mesothelioma is usually the most dangerous cancer. It contains unusual properties. The more I look at it the greater I am persuaded it does not work like a true solid flesh cancer. When mesothelioma can be a rogue viral infection, so there is the prospects for developing a vaccine plus offering vaccination for asbestos uncovered people who are really at high risk of developing upcoming asbestos associated malignancies. Thanks for revealing your ideas about this important health issue.

  2. Today, I went to the beachfront with my children. I found a sea shell and gave it to my 4 year old daughter and said “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She placed the shell to her ear and screamed. There was a hermit crab inside and it pinched her ear. She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is totally off topic but I had to tell someone!

  3. Hello there. I found your blog via Google while looking for a similar topic, your web site got here up. It seems good. I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks to visit then.

  4. Desde el Servicio técnico oficial de Bosch queremos facilitar y resolver cualquier tipo de duda, consulta, felicitación reclamación de nuestros productos servicios. Reparación de Electrodomésticos es la empresa, dedicada a las reparaciones, instalaciones y mantenimientos de electrodomésticos más económica de toda la Comunidad de Madrid, le ofrecemos la reparación de electrodomésticos de la forma más rápida, eficaz y barata. Servicio técnico de reparación de vitrocerámicas, placas de inducción y cocinas eléctricas en Madrid.

  5. Vaillant es una de las empresas líder en España en sistemas de calefacción y suministro de agua caliente sanitaria. Están construidos con tecnología punta y cuidadosamente diseñados, proporcionan agua caliente de forma rápida y eficaz en el hogar. Todas ellas pueden ser arregladas a la perfección y sin ningún tipo de problema por nuestros especialistas en Madrid y Valencia. Cuando nos llame, concretaremos la hora para mandarle a un técnico a domicilio para que realice la reparación cuanto antes.

  6. Si en algún momento detecta alguna avería en el frigorifico, llámenos, somos especialistas en reparación urgente de frigorificos Fagor, una de nuestras recepcionistas atenderá su llamada, y cuando sepamos que avería sufre su frigorifico uno de nuestros técnicos concretara con usted la hora para pasar a repararla. Si el cliente aprueba el presupuesto, en ese momento el técnico reparara la frigorifico y solamente le cobrara la cantidad que le ha dado de presupuesto. En todas las reparaciones de frigorificos Fagor, utilizamos repuestos originales de la casa y están garantizadas por escrito, Las reparaciones tienen tres meses de garantía en mano de obra.

  7. Los Servicios de Asistencia Técnica deben tener a la vista el precio por hora de la mano de obra, la indicación de que el cliente tiene derecho a un presupuesto previo por escrito advirtiendo de que en el caso de que finalmente no fuera aceptado se podría solicitar un precio por su elaboración, garantía de las reparaciones, horario de servicio al público, y la existencia de las Hojas de Reclamación a disposición del cliente.

  8. El Servicio técnico de reparación de secadoras Aeg ofrece a sus clientes rapidez y toda la garantía de una gran marca. SAT España Servicio Técnico Oficial, S.L. es un servicio técnico oficial regulado por la Comunidad Autónoma de Madrid, pero no es el servicio técnico oficial de la marca AEG. Visita, descuento y presupuesto gratuito en Horario de Lunes a Viernes de 8:00h a 18:00h.

  9. Empresa del sector comercial requiere estudiantes de mercadeo, ventas y publicidad con un excelente sentido de responsabilidad y servicio al cliente, que sea dinámico, emprendedor y tener un alto gusto por la atención y servicio al cliente. Se licita teleoperadores freen lance , segun su comodidad y tiempo, excelentes comisiones, se trabaja vendiendo marcas lideres en España y USA.

  10. Outsorcing Multinacional de Call Center requiere Técnicos, Tecnologos Estudiantes desde Cuarto semestre de carreras en sistemas, telecomunicaciones afines, que tengan mínimo (SEIS) meses de experiencia en soporte tecnico (Help Desk)Personalizado por Call Center. Requerimos personal técnica en sistemas,edad de 22 a 28 años con experencia minima de 1 año en digitación y manejo de archivos electronicos, disponibilidad de tiempo. Se requiere experiencia en tareas similares en obras sociales, excelente manejo de web y paquete Office.

  11. Teléfono, mapa e información sobre empresas y profesionales relacionados con Mecanizados Porriño. Mecanizados OSA, S.L. ha ido evolucionando paso a paso hasta convertirse en una empresa de reconocido prestigio en el mecanizado de piezas de precisión. AIKI es una empresa fundada en 2005 en el término municipal de Hernani, por la unión de dos trabajadores con una dilatada experiencia en el sector del metal.

  12. Desde su fundación Reparaciones y Mecanizados Godiz, fruto de la experiencia técnica de sus profesionales adquirida durante años, ha desempeñado un papel modesto pero cada vez más relevante para sus clientes. La impresión 3D es reconocida por sus ventajas en la creación de piezas con alta complejidad geométrica.

  13. Hay 31 localidades donde se encuentran resultados relacionados con Decoletaje De Precision. En nuestra dilatada experiencia hemos fabricado piezas de decoletaje para sectores tan variados como el automovilístico, el aeronáutico la defensa. El Decoletaje designa la fabricación de piezas de revolución (tornillos, ejes, bulones…), a partir de la mecanización de material en barra en rollo por arranque de viruta, mediante una herramienta de corte y para una fabricación en serie.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *