Rafale fighter jet performs during the Aero India air show at Yelahanka air base in Bengaluru
A Rafale fighter jet performs during the Aero India air show at Yelahanka air base in Bangalore on February 18, 2015. File Photo: Reuters / Abhishek N Chinnappa

The Supreme Court of India Wednesday dismissed the Narendra Modi-led government’s preliminary objections to review of an earlier judgment that had exonerated the government in the Rafale fighter jet deal, Asian News International reported.

In a move seen as detrimental to the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) ahead of general elections starting on April 11, the top court also allowed the admission of three ‘leaked’ documents in the Rafale case. They will be used as evidence in re-examining the review petitions filed against the Supreme Court’s December 14 judgment, which refused to order a probe of the procurement of 36 Rafale fighter jets from France. The petition was filed by former Union ministers Yashwant Sinha and Arun Shourie and lawyer-activist Prashant Bhushan.

The Rafale deal has become a major controversy with the opposition alleging corruption on the part of the current government.

Reacting to the Supreme Court’s judgment, Congress chief Rahul Gandhi told the media, “The Prime minister has been claiming that the Supreme Court had given him a clean chit on the Rafale deal. The Supreme Court has clarified and has begun an investigation into the Rafale deal.”

Earlier, the BJP-led government had told the Court that the plea for review of the Rafale verdict was not maintainable as it was based on documents that were protected under the British-era Official Secrets Act of 1923. It claimed that the documents were unauthorized photocopies of the originals kept in the Ministry of Defense and leaked into the public domain by the media.

But Justice KM Joseph had countered the government’s argument by referring to the Right to Information Act of 2005. He said RTI had revolutionized governance and had an “overriding effect” on the Official Secrets Act.

The Official Secrets Act is India’s anti-espionage law and provides the framework for dealing with spying, sedition and other potential threats to national security. Section 8(2) of the RTI act compels the government to disclose information “if public interest in disclosure outweighs the harm to protected interests.”

Petitioner Arun Shourie said, “Our argument was that because the documents relate to defense you must examine them. You asked for this evidence and we have provided it. So the Supreme Court has accepted our pleas and rejected the arguments of the government.”

One of the “leaked” documents was a dissent note by three senior Defense Ministry officials on the pricing of the Rafale jets. According to a report in the Indian daily newspaper daily The Hindu, the officials had concluded in the note that the new Rafale deal brokered by Prime Minister Modi was not on “better terms” than the earlier deal between Dassault Aviation and the previous United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government led by the Congress party. The old deal was for 126 aircraft, whereas the new deal is for 36.

Earlier, on December 14, the Supreme Court had rejected a petition seeking an independent probe into possible discrepancies in the Rafale jet deal. The petitioners had alleged fiscal malfeasance and commercial favoritism in the deal. The Court had found that there was “no occasion to doubt” the decision-making process behind the 2016 purchase of Rafale jets from Dassault Aviation in the Rs 1 billion deal.

Join the Conversation

1146 Comments

  1. Fantastic beat ! I would like to apprentice even as you amend your website, how can i subscribe for a weblog site? The account aided me a applicable deal. I have been a little bit familiar of this your broadcast provided vivid transparent idea

  2. Can I just say what a relief to find someone who actually knows what theyre talking about on the internet. You definitely know how to bring an issue to light and make it important. More people need to read this and understand this side of the story. I cant believe youre not more popular because you definitely have the gift.

  3. I intended to draft you the little remark so as to thank you once again for the gorgeous thoughts you have discussed on this site. It is certainly extremely open-handed of people like you to convey easily all that many people would have marketed for an e-book to help make some dough for their own end, most notably seeing that you could possibly have done it if you considered necessary. The advice in addition served as the great way to understand that most people have a similar zeal really like my very own to find out many more in terms of this problem. I believe there are many more enjoyable sessions up front for people who looked at your site.

  4. 채팅방 |친목 |만남사이트 |외로움 |CHAT |헌팅 |솔로 |무료채팅 |펜팔 |소개팅어플순위 |중개 |채팅어플 |중년 |만남 |소모임어플 |채팅사이트 |교제 |쪽지 |커플 |번개 |소개팅어플 |연인 |심심할때할만한것 |채팅 |남자소개팅옷 |채팅앱추천 |낯선사람과의대화 |데이트메이트 |유부녀남자친구 |번개팅 |무료만남어플 |이성친구 |카톡친구 |무료소개팅어플 |무료채팅어플 |눈팅 |사교춤 |급만남 |카페채팅 |심쿵어플 |CHATTING |돌싱카페 |오픈채팅방 |국제연애 |채팅앱 |체팅 |외국인친구사귀기 |여의도데이트 |중년채팅 |만남어플 |벙개 |하늘사랑채팅 |세이클럽타키 |무료채팅사이트 |여자꼬시는법 |심쿵소개팅 |해운대헌팅 |혼술집 |여자친구데이트 |은하수다방 |부산헌팅 |성인채팅 |골프조인방 |무료체팅 |앤조이 |카톡친구만들기 |부산채팅 |유료채팅 |건전한채팅 |아줌마채팅 |클럽채팅 |아바타채팅 |낯선사람과대화하기 |무료채팅추천 |광주채팅 |채팅사이트추천 |인터넷채팅사이트 |여자채팅 |이성채팅 |골프조인사이트 |제주채팅 |추천채팅 |채팅게임 |울산채팅 |지역별채팅 |소개팅남자옷 |건전한채팅사이트 |건전채팅 |분당산악회 |인천채팅 |등산회 |인기채팅사이트 |즉시만남 |출장대행 |만남앱 |중년취미 |20대채팅 |분당모임 |대구채팅 |인터넷채팅방 |재미교포결혼 |즐거운만남 |채팅방사이트 |완전무료채팅 |채팅만남사이트 |배트남여성 |지역채팅 |라이브채팅 |일대일채팅 |인기채팅 |미팅어플 |실시간대화 |주말동호회 |30대채팅 |돌싱소개팅 |즉석미팅 |무료만남 |일대일미팅 |챗팅 |중년소개팅 |여자만나는방법 |남친구함 |무료만남사이트 |킹카클럽 |아줌마만남 |커플메니저 |소개팅카페 |여자만나는법 |오프라인미팅 |인터넷음악방송 |결혼방법 |결혼상담관리사 |매칭사이트 |여자소개팅 |30대미팅 |남자친구사귀는법 |40대채팅 |소셜데이팅 |채팅싸이트 |채팅추천 |BJ방송 |20대미팅 |무료소개팅사이트 |부부만남 |무료재혼사이트 |쳇팅사이트 |부산미팅 |수원만남 |실시간만남 |만남채팅 |대구미팅 |체팅사이트 |소개팅주선 |등산모임 |청주결혼정보업체 |평일여행 |친구사귀기 |무료결혼상담소 |새로운만남 |무료소개팅 |남자친구구함 |남여만남 |40대미팅 |돌싱까페 |대구돌싱 |30대소개팅사이트 |실시간채팅 |40대만남 |인터넷소개팅 |만남주선사이트 |여친구함 |여자만나기 |여자만남 |인터넷채팅 |만남사이트추천 |채팅창 |울산만남 |채팅만남 |대화방 |여친구하기 |4050 |중매쟁이 |여자친구구함 |광주미팅 |주말산행 |매너만남 |인천만남 |이성친구만들기 |여자친구소개 |온라인채팅 |대전만남 |20대소개팅사이트 |40대모임 |컴퓨터채팅 |당일만남 |구미결혼정보회사 |커플만들기 |이성친구찾기 |소개팅미팅 |단체모임 |소개팅싸이트 |대구만남 |골프모임 |제주만남 |대학생소개팅 |광주만남 |번개만남 |중년모임 |대전미팅 |인터넷만남 |애인만들기 |만남주선 |3040미팅 |지역만남 |이성찾기 |애인만들기사이트 |서울미팅 |50대만남 |포항소개팅 |이성만남 |애인찾기 |돌싱동호회 |대학생미팅 |솔로탈출 |음악카페 |인연찾기 |미팅사이트 |여자친구사귀고싶어요 |모바일채팅 |애인구하기 |중년카페 |중년남성 |챗 |50대채팅 |만남싸이트 |소셜데이트 |채팅하기 |중년만남 |친구만남 |체팅싸이트 |이성교제 |제주결혼 |전북결혼정보회사 |인천결혼정보업체 |셀프소개팅 |맞선의상 |노인재혼 |기독교결혼 |결혼대행업체 |가톨릭결혼 |50대싱글모임 |포항결혼 |솔로여행 |커플메이커 |번팅 |40대채팅사이트 |연애사이트 |3040만남 |40대소개팅 |미팅카페 |10대채팅 |40대노총각 |공짜채팅 |무료챗팅 |중년채팅방 |무료채팅방 |청주채팅 |성인소개팅 |채팅방추천 |실시간체팅 |조이채팅 |음악채팅 |무료채팅창 |즉석만남 |데이트알바 |엔조이사이트 |벙개모임 |인터넷무료채팅 |성인만남사이트 |아이폰낯선사람 |낯선사람과의대화포인트버그 |가가라이브사진 |가가라이브신고 |가가라이브위치추적 |가가홈런 |가가랑ㅣ브 |가가라이브어플 |라인여자 |가가라이브인증 |가가라이브라인 |가가라이브신상 |가가라이브정지 |가가라이브 |포인트없는만남 |결제없는소개팅어플 |포인트없는만남사이트 |결제없는만남 |채팅 |가가라이브같은 |가가라이브여자 |가가라이브2 |가가라이브레전드 |가가런 |무료번개 |가가라이브3 |가가라이브같은곳

  5. I got what you intend, appreciate it for posting.Woh I am glad to find this website through google. “Since the Exodus, freedom has always spoken with a Hebrew accent.” by Heinrich Heine.

  6. I like this weblog so much, saved to bookmarks. “Respect for the fragility and importance of an individual life is still the mark of an educated man.” by Norman Cousins.

  7. certainly like your web-site but you need to check the spelling on several of your posts. Many of them are rife with spelling issues and I in finding it very bothersome to inform the reality however I’ll certainly come back again.