Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Chinese President Xi Jinping have been meeting once again, in Wuhan on Saturday. The shadow of Doklam is now subsumed by the larger shadow of the looming trade war and the threatened rollback of globalization.
US President Donald Trump has fired the first shot with sanctions targeting US$100 billion of Chinese imports. If not checked, the consequent economic bloodshed might result in the collapse of the globalization arrangements that set off the greatest expansion of the world economy in the last three decades. This equally threatens the economic well-being of China and India.
Clearly globalization has benefited China the most, but India too has hugely benefited by it. While China has a huge market for its manufactured goods in the US and had a trade surplus of US$245 billion in 2017, India had in the US an information-technology market of $120 billion last year.
The value addition of India’s IT exports vastly exceeds the value addition generated by China’s export of manufactured goods to the US. The high economic growth rates in both countries owe a great deal to their trade with the United States and the substantial trade deficits the US has with both countries. Thus for the first time in decades the most immediate and important interests of India and China coincide. Both leaders will see the need to act in concert. Clearly this should be at the top of the Xi-Modi agenda in Wuhan.
Next on the agenda will almost certainly be the huge trade gap in favor of China that has resulted in India directly contributing about $400 billion to China since the turn of this century. Of this, about $250 billion has happened in the last five years. The reduction of this will almost certainly be next on the agenda. India has been hoping that China would mitigate this somewhat by investing in India, preferably by commercial foreign direct investment, instead of the investment Indian economists believe is a debt trap.
India has been skeptical about the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) economic play as little more than a grand scheme to run down Chinese reserves in US banks and relieve China’s industrial overcapacity in its infrastructure-related sectors such as cement, steel and power generation. In this manner the zero-earning reserves are converted into interest-bearing loans to hapless countries such as Pakistan, Sri Lanka and others. Sri Lanka is already feeling the bite of the Hambantota “investments” and has to restructure the debt by giving the port and 7,700 hectares on a 99-year lease to a Chinese state-owned enterprise.
China is bound to express its concern about joining the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue, a quasi-alliance of the US, Japan, Australia and India favored by American strategists. It is just a Western wish. India knows what is in its own interests and what is not. The US and Australia are separated from China by vast oceans and enjoy a sense of security that India cannot. India has a big land border with China and it will feel the immediate consequences of any conflict. Besides, the US and Japan are much too closely economically integrated with China to be taken as credible allies by India. If India knows anything, it knows it stands alone.
India didn’t take part in the BRI because there was nothing of interest to it in it. When China makes a proposal that incorporates India into its worldview, India will respond suitably. Otherwise India has no intention of paying court to the “Emperor Far Away.” There are indications that there is a belated realization of this in China now. The greater economic integration of India and China is the best hope for China and India’s sustained long-term growth.
The fates of India and China in a world of rapid economic, technological and social change are inextricably linked. The gross domestic products of India and China within the next two decades will exceed that of the Group of Seven. A major global power shift is under way. India and China must wake up to this reality instead of living out the childish fantasies of their half-baked and under-educated “strategic experts.”
Well written article, but it does not mention the unease China feels about Indian economic and nuclear clout, not to mention its close proximity to Western democracies. By blocking Indian entry into NSG, China is playing petty politics to keep it’s concubine Pakistan happy. Soon China will realize that pakis are infected and terminally sick…and no amount of Chinese medicine is going to work.
india’s a joke. it has no foreign policy other than playing powers off eachother. when you try to please everyone, you end up pleasing no one. it is indeed alone
Excellent out-of-box synopsis of the tasks at hand for the leaders to begin a meaningful negotiation to find the greatest common denominator for the benefits of both nations.
The wisdom in the article rang clearly above the usual cacophonic jingoism.
For 2000 years (300BC-1700AD) both India and China each produced roughly 1/3 of world’s wealth. The remaining world – Europe, Middle East, Africa, Americas the rest 1/3.
The rise of the West was a fluke of history, made possible by the stupidity of the Kaliphate that milked East-West trade with Tariffs (Arabic word) living off others.Then finally 500 years ago Europeans expelled Muslims and Jews from spain freeing themselves to find new routes to Asia.
Success of West is best explained by Samuel Huntington.
” .. The West won the world not by the superiority of its ideas or values or religion, but rather by its superiority in applying organized violence. Westerners often forget this fact, non-Westerners never do ”. —— The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order, p. 51. ..
Now West’s violence payoff is negative so is on a banana peel below replenishment; fully 53% of US GDP is "hegemonic" and will disappear soon.
Why can India not sell IT services to China in exchange for goods? Both will benefit unconditionally.
China has regained its traditional place, for India to do the same it must rid itself of 3 nefarious foreign divisive influences.
1. Iranian Aryanism that infused it with racist Caste System
2. Umarite Judaic Islam that prevented India’s natural development
3. European Democracy, rule of the Demos (5% moneyed males) that decimated its sustainable culture
China was lucky to have escaped all 3 nefarious influences. India must return to its unified pre-Aryan roots. Neither INC nor Modi will take her there. Who will?