Hitler comparisons are never, ever, a smart ploy to win an argument. Tell that to Japanese officials who just can’t seem to quit citing the 20th century’s most-hated genocidal maniac. Case in point: Deputy Prime Minister Taro Aso.
In 2013, the 76-year-old Aso celebrated the process surrounding the “Nazi German constitution.” He asked, at the time: “Why don’t we learn from their tactics?”
It seems Aso hasn’t learned from his own tactics. This week, he courted fresh controversy when he told some Japanese lawmakers he agreed with Hitler’s motives.
Aso declared: “Hitler, who killed millions of people, was no good even if his motive was right.”
That, just two months after a top Bank of Japan policymaker, Yutaka Harada, waxed poetic about Hitler’s “wonderful” fiscal and monetary stimulus steps.
Harada’s bizarre comments drew a rebuke from the Simon Wiesenthal Center, as did Aso’s this week.
“This is not the first time that members of Japan’s elite publicly expressed their admiration for some elements of Hitler and Nazi Germany,” the Los Angeles-based human rights group said.
“Each of these incidents creates deep unease among Japan’s neighbors and friends.”
One of those incidents involved former Osaka Mayor Toru Hashimoto, who certain politicians compared with Adolf Hitler.
One of those incidents involved former Osaka Mayor Toru Hashimoto, who certain politicians compared with Adolf Hitler.
“This may not be the most appropriate analogy, but his powerful oratory skills are just like Hitler when he was young,” former Tokyo Governor Shintaro Ishihara said of Hashimoto in 2012.
Uh, no, it’s not appropriate, particularly coming from Ishihara, a nationalist with his own track record of racist gaffes.
In 2014, more than 300 copies of Ann Frank’s “The Diary of a Young Girl” were vandalized in public libraries around the nation.
In April, Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s Cabinet approved the return of Adolf Hitler’s “Mein Kampf” memoir to Japanese classrooms.
Tokyo also allowed schools to use the long-defunct Imperial Rescript on Education, a 19th-century call to patriotism instrumental to mindsets behind Japan’s disastrous World War II adventure.
What, oh what, gives? Such comments and gestures get lost in translation at a moment when Abe seeks to increase Japan’s global “soft power” and diplomatic footprint.
What, oh what, gives? Such comments and gestures get lost in translation at a moment when Abe seeks to increase Japan’s global “soft power” and diplomatic footprint.
But then, so do many of his policies like revising the pacifist post-war constitution against public opinion.
Abe also courted controversy in 2014 for tapping Eriko Yamatani to head the National Public Safety Commission.
She spent much her tenure trying to deny long-time ties to an internationally condemned ultranationalist group Zaitokukai that targets the Korean community.
Yamatani was also among the parade of Cabinet members irking Korea and China with visits to Yasukuni Shrine, a symbol of Japan’s past militarism.
In May, Tokyo-based reporters Jake Adelstein and Mari Yamamoto penned a Daily Beast article headlined “Shinzo Abe’s Government Has a Thing About Hitler. It Likes Him.”
In it, they say some of Abe’s other policy moves seem right out of the Nazi playbook. They include an ambiguous state secrets bill that could put journalists and whistleblowers in jail and a security bill that brings Steven Speilberg’s “Minority Report” film — arrests on suspected crimes — to life.
In their piece, subtitled “To Heil and Back,” Adelstein and Yamamoto muse about another science-fiction work, the hit TV series “The Man In the High Castle” which imagines a reality in which the Nazis and Imperial Japan won the second world war.
Nationalists often spend too much mythologizing a past that might’ve been and not enough at a fast-approaching future (Donald Trump comes to mind here, too).
Abe’s revival scheme, Abenomics, is a case in point, trying to recreate an economic model that thrived in the 1980s, but no longer exists in a world increasingly dominated by China and other Asian upstarts.
Aso moved to take back his latest misstatement. “It was inappropriate that I cited Hitler as an example and I would like to retract that,” he said in a statement on Wednesday.
The trouble with such gaffes, aside from the obvious affront to human decency, is the backward-looking worldview they betray.
This, after all, is Abe’s deputy and finance minister, a man who should be gearing Abenomics for the world it will confront 75 years from now.
Instead, his mind is on the events of 75 years ago — and the worst ones, at that.
(William Pesek is a Tokyo-based journalist, former columnist for Barron’s and Bloomberg and author of “Japanization: What the World Can Learn from Japan’s Lost Decades.” Twitter: @williampesek)
Those were not ‘gaffes’ at all. Those words showed true colors so glaring and prevalent among them, they were just unable to hide behind their pacifist facade.
People, especially Americans, completely forget that the Japanese imperialists are the most fervent allies of Hitler during WWII. The current right wing crowd lead by Shino Abe, a grandson who admires his WWII war criminal grandfather, are deep in their mind admirers of Hitlers.
Abe’s retraction of his Hitler statement sounds like someone who made a faux pas at a dinner party.
Can’t help adding my bit here. From my sojourn in many countries over the lasr 40 years, I have to say that the ordinary people in every one of those countries are basically very nice people. Of course there will also be the bad, and ugly, but really they are a small minority as a percentage of the population. Where countries get a bad name, it is mostly the result the actions, words and deeds of those elites who hold political power and those who are associated with such people. A few modern day classic examples are the US, Japan and N. Korea.
I honestly feel that the ordinary Japanese folks are nice people. However, for some unfathomable reasons, those holding the political reins just so naturally gravitate to adopting a militaristic schizophrenic mentality, non-stop glorifying of their condemned war monsters, and refusing, unrepentant or trying to shut off from their national consciousness(unlike the Germans) for all the heinous crimes committed against humanity. Is it any wonder then that there are still rogues holding high office in Japan who feel it natural to spout their admiration for things Nazi? They may be adorned in coat tails wearing high hats trying to make themselves look like( penguin version?) a British gentleman, but I am sure what is under that hat has not changed a bit – its still hoping to cry "banzai" again! People of Asia, Watch out !!!
Bunch of murderous Nazi left over that glorify war , inhumanity and atrocity in japan. Worst than beasts.
Its not a gaffe at all. They said what they mean. It was only the media storm that prompted the "regret" just tlike their "regret" for the war and the comfort women. The LDP is full of these kind of bastards. Everytime one quits from a "gaffe", another one pops up. Thats why Abe is hankering for round 2 of the Japan China war. The Japanese felt that they should have done better while Chinese wants payback. There are many many unresolved issues. And worse of all, hundreds of thousands of US soldiers died fighting a vicious war with the Japanese and now cosndier them as "best friends forever".
Linky to Yamamoto and Adelstein’s article:
http://www.thedailybeast.com/japan-shinzo-abes-government-has-a-thing-about-hitler-it-likes-him
Those who try to revise history are doomed too never learn from it. �