As a Chinese-American I am worried by the seemly bizarre statements and actions by the president-elect, Donald Trump.
He is now surrounded by neocon advisors who wish to confront China. China bashing has dire consequences for Chinese-Americans. In fact all Asian-Americans should worry, after all most Americans couldn’t tell the difference between a Korean, Japanese or Chinese.
Back in the late 70s and early 80s Japan bashing was in vogue. Two laid off auto workers killed a Chinese-American, mistook him as Japanese, accusing him of stealing their jobs. There is already an increase of hate crimes targeting Chinese. Today I would not want to work in the defense industry as I did once. I worked on underwater submarine detection, for which I received secret clearance. It was based on using differential magnetometers, a field closely related to my Ph.D. thesis. It is ironic in view of the latest flap of US unmanned underwater drones recovered by the Chinese. Too many ethnic Chinese have been wrongly accused of spying. Worse things could happen to us if the current trend continues.
Ever since the re-establishment and reconciliation started with Nixon’s historic visit in 1972 and later the formal recognition of People’s Republic of China by Carter in 1979, the two countries were on the mend. Under the leadership of Deng Xiaoping China began a long period of growth and recovery. In three decades, its economy grew from a very low base to the world’s second largest today, in part due to its shift to an open market system helped by foreign direct investments. Most of the initial foreign direct investments came from overseas Chinese Diaspora including Hong Kong and Taiwan.
Hong Kong’s manufacturing sector essentially moved across the border. Many Taiwan industries did the same. The bilateral relationship between US and China has been and should be a win-win situation. Chinese workers found jobs and China lifted more than 500 million out of poverty while the rest of the world benefitted from low cost and affordable goods. American lives have improved as a result.
China used its surplus to buy US Treasury bonds thereby lowered US interest rates. The historical low mortgage rates allow Americans to buy homes and put extra cash in their pockets and it kept inflation at bay.
Did China steal American jobs or rape America as Trump claim? Hardly!
American companies have for years had overseas factories in many Asian countries as well as in Mexico. China, unlike Japan, is very open to direct foreign investments. American companies as well as European, Japanese and Korean companies have many factories there. Two way- trades reached US$627 billion in 2015, more than US’s trade with Japan, UK and Germany combined. China is now America’s third largest export market.
With China’s new growing middle class its market is now fulfilling the long term dream of selling to the Chinese. It was once said if every Chinese were to buy an aspirin that would be more than one billion. These days they are buying that and more. GM now sells more cars in China than in the US from cars made and sold in China. By the way those sales are not considered as US exports even though the profits generated belong to GM and its shareholders.
That is just one example. Apple assembles its phones in China with parts mostly from the US and other foreign countries; the total value of the phone is “credited “to Chinese exports thereby distorting the true trade balance. Greater China is also Apple’s largest foreign market though its share has been declining in recent quarters due to local competition. This is a symbiotic relationship that benefits both. Zachary Karabell in his book entitled: Superfusion spells out the mutual benefits of that relationship. That is hardly what Trump and his ill advised advisors want to hear.
China’s “sins” according to America, from Obama now Trump is it’s too successful. China’s slowly but surely rising threatens American domination in the Pacific. Henry Kissinger in his book “On China” stated there are some in our State Department who subscribe to the thesis that a successful Chinese “rise” is incompatible with America’s position in the Pacific and by extension in the world. America has tried to destabilize China for years with its covert support of Tibetans and Uyghurs and openly selling military equipment to Taiwan contrary to the Joint Communiqué between US and China signed in 1972. Even the so called “umbrella movement” in Hong Kong is funded by National Endowment for Democracy (NED).
America encouraged its allies Japan and the Philippines to do its beckoning by stoking aggressive confrontation with China in territorial disputes. How could supporting a revisionist Japan or call the South China Sea, the “West Philippine Sea” promote peace in the Far East? The so called Trans-Pacific Partnership, now seem to be dead on arrival, nominally seeks to manage trade, promote growth, and regionally integrate the economies of the Asia-Pacific region. It is telling China the second biggest economy in the world and a Pacific country is excluded. China is now surrounded by many hostile states.
China’s launching of Asian Infrastructural Investment Bank (AIIB) which will benefit a wide stretch of Asian countries that desperately need improvement in their roads, bridges and ports was spun by the US. In fact it pressured other countries not to join. That effort failed miserably when America’s closest allies starting with UK and then other major European and Asian countries joined. As of today there are 57 founding members with 30 more waiting to join. This leaves US and Japan as the only two major countries looking in. There is universal agreement that this is one of Obama administration’s biggest foreign policy blunders.
Ever since China’s ascent it’s been accused by US as a currency manipulator even though it held its currency steady in the face of the Asian financial crisis in 1997 when most countries in Asia devaluated theirs. Since then the U.S. has continue to print money thereby lowering its value. But it is called Quantitative Easing. There have been many QEs since. How about Japan whose currency has depreciated more than 30%? But Japan is considered an ally and therefore gets a free pass.
Why is the US trying to destabilize China? China is blamed for all America’s woes. It’s not just Trump. After all Obama and his former Secretary State Clinton were the chief architects of “pivot to Asia” a thinly disguised attempt to contain China that fools no one.
So what did China do exactly to deserve all the negativity? Has China threatened America? Does China have military bases surrounding America or send its fleets or planes close to its territory to monitor its activities? The answer is no. By contrast Australian documentary film maker John Pilger noted: Today, more than 400 American military bases encircle China with missiles, bombers, warships and, above all, nuclear weapons. From Australia north through the Pacific to Japan, Korea and across Eurasia to Afghanistan and India, the bases form, says one US strategist, “the perfect noose.”
Does the US really want regime change in China? Even in China’s darkest days it held onto its territory. Surely it will not let any foreign country interfere with its internal policies or tear it apart. As founding Prime Minister of Singapore Lee Kwan Yew said: internally China needs stability externally China need peace. China is not a threat to America or any other country. Quoting Prime Minister Lee again: China wants to be China and accepted as such, not an honorary member of the West.

quote: "China’s leaders are evil people."
All of them? How do you know? Sources? Details?
Those leaders have been drawn from the population at large over time. Would you contend that perhaps the Chinese population in general are evil?
James Pere yeah, stick to the Japanese. casual racism lurks everywhere. shame on you Dr Chai.
Richard! It’s not ”what did China do exactly to deserve all the negativity? Has China threatened America?” it’s what CHINA has done to its own people, from Nobel literarure winners to artists like Ai Wei Wei and human rights lawyers. China is an evil empire. This does not mean Americans will attack Chinese ethnic people in the USA. We know the difference. Even Kissinger knows it is an evil empire. Do you know he has never visited Taiwan and cannot do so ever ever unless he gets permission from the CCP in Beijing. And they will never give him permission. You stand up fora country like China PRC? Sir?
Richard L King Peter Navarro’s name in Chinese characters is written as 納瓦羅 or as 納瓦洛 (Peter Navarro) in Chinese traditional characters in free, democratic sovereign, independent Taiwan……..BUT as 纳瓦罗(Peter Navarro)in the Communist Dictatorship of China in their Chinese simplified characters as ordained (dictated) by Mao Tse-dung.
Dr Peter Navarro’s name in Chinese characters is written as 納瓦羅 or as 納瓦洛 (Peter Navarro) in Chinese traditional characters in free, democratic sovereign, independent Taiwan……..BUT as 纳瓦罗(Peter Navarro)in the Communist Dictatorship of China in their Chinese simplified characters as ordained (dictated) by Mao Tse-dung.
Taiwan and China are two different countries and there is no ONE CHINA. There are two countries here, one called Taiwan and the other called China. Taiwan’s official name is THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA, and China’s official name is THE PEOPLES REPUBLIC OF CHINA, which is a brazen euphemistic lie since Communist China is in no way run by the PEOPLE of CHINA at all but by the brutal dictactorship of Xi Xiping and the USSR-like Chinese Communist Party.
Richard, in all due respect: Fair and honest criticism of Israel does not have dire consequences for American Jews and criticism of Communist China will NOT have dire consequences for Chinese Americans or Taiwanese Americans. Peter Navarro himself has never sad or written negative things about the Chinese people as an ethnic group; he has onlu criticized the Communist Party thug state of Commie China and he is right to do so. China’s leaders are evil people. The West must stand up to them. Chinese people in the West too. You, too. Remember the USSR, sir? Remember Hitler? What are you afraid of. Americans are not going to confuse Chinese Americans and TaiwaneseAmericans with the evil practices of the PRC, which is not a PEOPLE’s republic by any means, a true euphemism if ever there was on. PEOPLE have not say in China. THE CCP runs it all. Stand up to them. BTW, Richard, I know you and respect you and see this too: Peter Navarro’s name in Chinese characters is written as 納瓦羅 or as 納瓦洛 (Peter Navarro) in Chinese traditional characters in free, democratic sovereign, independent Taiwan……..BUT as 纳瓦罗(Peter Navarro)in the Communist Dictatorship of China in their Chinese simplified characters as ordained (dictated) by Mao Tse-dung.
December 25, 2016 A.D. [”Anno Donaldo”]
SPOT THE DIFFERENCES?
NOTE TO INTL MEDIA:
Dr Peter Navarro’s name in Chinese characters is written as 納瓦羅 or as 納瓦洛 (Peter Navarro) in Chinese traditional characters in free, democratic sovereign, independent Taiwan……..BUT as 纳瓦罗(Peter Navarro)in the Communist Dictatorship of China in their Chinese simplified characters as ordained (dictated) by Mao Tse-dung.
Taiwan and China are two different countries and there is no ONE CHINA. There are two countries here, one called Taiwan and the other called China. Taiwan’s official name is THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA, and China’s official name is THE PEOPLES REPUBLIC OF CHINA, which is a brazen euphemistic lie since Communist China is in no way run by the PEOPLE of CHINA at all but by the brutal dictactorship of Xi Xiping and the USSR-like Chinese Communist Party.
Bravo. This is an article very well written and gives a balanced view of what is really happening in this world. China bashing, Japan bashing and etc show human weakness which is always exploited by ruthless politicians. This is a case of bashing thy neighbours when they are getting close to where you are. In Chinese it is "憎富厭貧".
Nice bit of casual racism at Japanese chucked in for good measure…
some very good points are made here. But I would not take Trump too seriously. He is a rather impulsive man, but I think he will do the right thing in the end. He is a super, pro American. We will see.FGC
What Trump and his inner circle have said and deliberately hyped are of course detestable, but to think that the sentiments they voiced are peculiar to only the few fiats would be missing the forest. There is a very large fraction of the US population who think, and want to act, similarly to what Trump and advisers are espousing. This has come about gradually and insidiously over many decades, through media opinion abetting and people’s own frustration of doing poorly but conveniently pointing fingers at others. China’s nascent success makes China the stand-out focus of blames and hatred. Had Sanders been elected instead of Trump, I suspect the internal political dynamics in the US would have led to similar policy stance of the US government.
I don’t think there is a way to correct this course of political evolution. It is as inevitable as Hitler’s rise 90 years ago in Deutsche Land. I believe China’s effort to protect itself against such evil would best be placed on cleansing itself of corruption and traitors, doubling down on building militarily strength as the deterrent, and be psychologically prepared for the worst case scenario.
quote: "Does the US really want regime change in China?"
Not a precise question, but the answer is YES, with some qualifying remarks – it’s not the American people, not state or municipal governments. It’s not even the US government as a whole, notwithstanding the puppets planted by the real, shadow powers in the White House, Congress, and the Supreme Court.
Some members of state / local governments and many in general population may have been influenced by decades of anti-communist propaganda and distorted reports (with an agenda) from the mainstream media (e.g. CNN, NY Times, Washington Post, Wall St. Journal etc), and may therefore support ideas of regime change, but they do not have any inherent interests of their own.
The Money Trust (or the shadow government, aka the power that be in America and Europe, Britain included) has an inherent interest in regime change in China and Russia. This is the group that collectively control private central banks of the West.
The "money changers", as the greedy, thievish, morally defunct money lenders were called in Jesus days in Jerusalem and parts of Europe where Jews had been admitted, have had a long history of plotting regime changes and wars. The murder of King Charles I of England in 1649 was an illuminating example of their Modus Operandi.
I highly recommend a recent book by John Hamer, "Behind the Curtain" (May 2016).
"The Secrets of the Federal Reserve" by Eustace Mullins
(1952) is a must-read for anyone who wants to understand the source and nature of political power in the US (and quite a few countries with private central banks in Europe).
The lesson to be drawn from American history is not inclusiveness, but Japanese internment in World War 2 and Chinese anti immigration laws overturned not so long ago.
Thank you. It really is a shame that America chose to confront and even try to contain China. The two countries are competible in so many ways. I hope we don’t fall into the Thucydides Trap.
This is a good summary of the relationship of the US and China since Nixon’s time. Each side is increasingly dependent on the other for economic well-being. Cooperation is better for both countries and for the world. It’s time the US accepts the reality of China’s rise and respects its unique system and 5000 years of history. It cannot be made to fit in the Western model. In the end, AIIB will prove to be a more winning strategy than destruction of war.
Turbulent days ahead for America. It is Trump versus the World. He hates the UN, hates China, hates the Latinos and Blacks. Anyway he thinks Putin will "love" him…more likely he is going to find out the reality soon.
Good luck to America. Many Americans hate Trump and wanted him to be rejected as the President-elect. I can see that Trump will be trumped by his own myopic foolishness. America will descend into chaos. The gigantic American bureaucracy is not going to be brow-beaten by a foolish Trump.
Sorry for the Chinese Americans…you are living in difficult times in USA. I have no plans to be in USA anytime soon. So glad to be a Chinese and living in the Far-East. Trump is not welcomed here.
Oh yes, I am going to make lots of money from my American investments and I do not need to thank Trump.
US maintains its global power by its overwhelming military might. A lot of money, men, and resources must be fed to the leviathan. The money, men, and resources are no problems as long as US maintains the dollar hegemony, and the world must use the US dollar to trade. US prints its money while everyone else must earn it and save it. When America creates money, its economy will be stimulated, but the rest of the world will suffer inflation a few years down the road. Wherever parts of the world suffer turmoil and conflicts, people will hoard US dollars. In a sense, everyone pays towards the US ‘Defense’ budget. US can threaten everyone with sanctions but not vice versa. The dollar hegemony in turn depends on the projection of US power by its military. China’s rise challenges the dollar hegemony. Without dollar hegemony, US cannot create money at will, and therefore cannot sustain its military budget to subjugate the world, which by the way, includes US citizens who also pay. The party will be over for some people. This is a serious challenge which the powers that be can understand very well. On the other hand, the people who has the power and the wealth and the wherewithal to protect their wealth cannot afford hot war with a major power. The threat is that these people may very well lose all their wealth if not their lives. So they will set their dogs to bark and bite and use dark arts and propaganda (including China bashing) to subvert but crazy war talk is just a tactic in game theory for gaining advantage. It’s known since Nixon times. China bashing is a bi-partisan sport and it is also a popular sport. It’s mostly based on lies, half-truths, and false narratives. It depends on the media to spread the lies as truth, and depends on the somnolent American public to swallow the lies without question. America is a democracy. Its citizens should be responsible for its government and representatives and the behaviour of the media. Since the American people have elected Donald Trump to represent them, showing the world the true character of the American soul, we shouldn’t hold out much hope for America’s China bashing to abate.
Well said, Richard! China bashing is just as bad for Americans who are not ethnic Chinese. There is now a deliberate attempt to worsen relarions with China, to create a new Cold War in the Pacific. Ths is a very stupid move, but the Trump types and their Navarro propagandists hope to make lots of profit from this supidity. What upsets them is mainly that they see their "Big Dog" dominant position in Asia threatened by the rise of the Chinese people. All the rest mainly consist of excuses for their militaristic approach. But the facts will show that Asia’s rise, China’s rise is unstoppable, and that it will be very good for us in the end. None of the basic challenges facing the whole human race can be met without cooperation between America and China.
"Does the US really want regime change in China?" Of course the answer is a resounding yes.
Richard, Nicely put, thanks.
Hi Richard,
Good job done.Thanks for standing up for us CAs What you said in the article is 100% correct.
" Does the US really want regime change in China? Even in China’s darkest days it held onto its territory. Surely it will not let any foreign country interfere with its internal policies or tear it apart."
Keep it up!
George Lo
Walnut Creek, Ca
Richard,
Well saaid, especially the quote from Prime Minister Lee that : "China wants to be China and accepted as such, not an honorary member of the West." This is so different from the mentality of the Japanese, where they would "kill all, burn all and loot all" in her invasion of China, so that they can join the Colonial West. Too bad that they are just too short, standing invisibly behind the 6-ft Westerners.
David Chai, Foster City, CA