If the Germans don’t have children, does it matter who inherits their country? Why not their house pets?

An alley cat from the streets of Rome inherited 10 million Euros from a wealthy widow named Maria Assunta who died childless in 2011. An Indian couple recently left their house and bank account to a pet monkey. A New York accountant left $1.5 million earlier this year to a Maltese terrier. And a German shepherd named Guenther came into $145 million when his owner, the German Countes Karlotta Liebenstein, passed away fifteen years ago. If childless people leave money to their pets, all the more so should childless peoples bequeath their countries to human refugees, who obviously deserve to have Germany more than the Germans’ domestic animals.

German women on average bear just 1.3 children against a replacement rate of 2.1, which means that they will disappear within a foreseeable future horizon.


At present fertility rates, the United Nations projects a decline in Germany’s under-thirty population from almost 25 million today to barely 10 million at the end of the present century. Critics of German Chancellor Angela Merkel’s welcoming policy towards Middle Eastern and African migrants complain that this will radically change Germany’s character. But what did they have in mind?

If the Germans won’t have children, someone else will settle their land. The only question is who. Here the Germans are baffled. It makes no sense to take in barely-educated Arabs, a fifth of whom are illiterate, as Clemens Wergin argued in Die Welt Sept. 5: “It was a mistake to bring unskilled workers from culturally backward Mediterranean countries during the ‘economic miracle’ years [of the 1960s]…that was as true for workers from the south of Italy as from Anatolia. The jobs they took were the first to fall victim to automation and to outsourcing to low-wage countries. Often a poorly-educated welfare-state proletariat was left behind…Muslim immigrants to Europe have experienced a tradition backlash that mirrors the experience of Muslim societies in the Middle East. That not only raises the hurdle for integration into European society, but has created a serious security problem.”

What Wergin writes is as reasonable as it is irrelevant to his country’s present mood.  Wergin’s term “culturally backward” is a trigger word, in today’s politically correct usage. What does it mean to be culturally advanced? Germany cited its superior culture as a justification for its position during the First World War. As Peter Watson wrote in his 2010 book The German Genius, “On October 4, 1914, two months into the Great War, ninety-three German intellectuals published . . . the Manifesto of the Ninety-Three, addressed ‘An die Kulturwelt’ (To the Civilized World), in which they . . . made it clear they viewed the war not as a campaign against German militarism but above all as an assault on German culture.” Watson reports that the great sociologist Max Weber wrote in 1916, “It would be shameful if we lacked the courage to ensure that neither Russian barbarism nor French grandiloquence ruled the world. That is why this war is being fought.”

Germany’s defeat in the Great War ruined its confidence in its culture. The celebrated Nazi dictum (spoken by a character in Hans Johst’s 1934 play “Schlageter”), “When I hear the word ‘culture’ I reach for my pistol,” usually is taken to mean that the Nazis were boors. That is not true; Hitler began as an artist and loved classical music. Rather, it meant that the generation that bled out in the cause of culture wanted to hear no more exhortations on the subject. In place of culture, the Nazis rallied Germany to fight for race. That didn’t work out for them either.

German culture doubtless was the gold standard of the West by the last quarter of the 18th century; virtually everything of importance in philosophy, science, mathematics and literature was said first (or said only) in German, while German composers utterly dominated classical music. But it had a flaw.

The great German cultural project that began with the generation of J.W. Goethe and Immanuel Kant proposed to accomplish everything that religion had promised to accomplish, but without God. Goethe’s “Faust” is the most biblical of modern works of literature and deservedly the most influential. Kant proposed a wholly secular ethics. Magnificent as the project was, and as fruitful as it became, it failed. Nietzsche retorted that “we (the German intellectuals) have killed God, and now nothing is forbidden.” In God’s absence, German thinking slid into relativism and Nihilism, with Nietzsche as its anti-prophet. Nietzsche and the existential philosopher Martin Heidegger (who joined the Nazi party and never recanted) were the heirs of Kant and Goethe.

I do not mean to diminish Germany’s accomplishments; there are things in the Hebrew Bible I never would have understood without seeing them through Goethe’s eyes. But I know very few Germans who bother to read Goethe, much less think much about him. Two world wars soured the Germans on their own culture.

To declare that semi-literate Arab refugees  do not meet the cultural qualifications for integration into German society implies that there is a cultural standard to begin with. That is a concept that most Germans (evidently including Chancellor Angela Merkel) cannot bear to pronounce. One suspects that Germans have so few children because they do not like themselves, their history or their culture to begin with. In that case, why should they require anyone else to adhere to a cultural standard they eschew themselves? And if they dislike their culture so much as to head towards extinction, does it matter to them that another culture–brutal as it might be–will replace theirs?

(Copyright 2015 Asia Times Holdings Limited, a duly registered Hong Kong company. All rights reserved. Please contact us about sales, syndication and republishing.)


David Paul Goldman (born September 27, 1951) is an American economist, music critic, and author, best known for his series of online essays in the Asia Times under the pseudonym Spengler. Goldman sits on the board of Asia Times Holdings.

Join the Conversation


  1. When I initially commented I clicked the “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get several emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove me from that service? Thank you!

  2. I think other site proprietors should take this site as an model, very clean and magnificent user friendly style and design, let alone the content. You’re an expert in this topic!

  3. Aw, it was a very good post. In concept I have to devote writing like this moreover – taking time and actual effort to make a great article… but what things can I say… I procrastinate alot through no means seem to get something carried out.

  4. I know this if off topic but I’m looking into starting my own weblog and was curious what all is required to get setup? I’m assuming having a blog like yours would cost a pretty penny? I’m not very web smart so I’m not 100 positive. Any tips or advice would be greatly appreciated. Kudos

  5. Good site! I really love how it is easy on my eyes and the data are well written. I’m wondering how I might be notified whenever a new post has been made. I have subscribed to your RSS feed which must do the trick! Have a great day!

  6. Hello, I think your blog might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your blog in Chrome, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, superb blog!

  7. I wish to show my admiration for your kind-heartedness supporting folks who really want help with that matter. Your special dedication to passing the solution along had been extremely beneficial and has helped people much like me to achieve their objectives. Your entire warm and helpful recommendations signifies this much a person like me and even more to my office colleagues. With thanks; from each one of us.

  8. DAEWOO ha desaparecido como fabricante, en España (frigorñificos Combi) y en su país de origen, Corea, donde ha cerrado/vendido sus plantas de fabricación de electrodomésticos. Elk Servicio ese que dices, depende de la central de HAIER, y es allí donde reclamar y denunciar en su caso. Los A.A. son más malos que un dolor de muelas,cuando los pones en bomba de calor petan el plástico de la estructura del split. En cuanto al precio, es algo más barato el HAIER, pero no me hagas a mí decidir tu compra. Este especialista a los pocos meses hizo suspensión de pagos y vinieron a verme los cabezas de HAIER A.A. de España para que les llevara la posventa.

  9. A diferencia del anterior el aire que aspira también es del exterior, para aprovechar el aire a mayor temperatura. Nuestro servicio técnico de lavadoras, están disponibles de lunes a viernes de 9 a 20h y sábado de 9 a 2h en la reparación de electrodomésticos. Los técnicos están atentos para realizar los servicio técnico de lavadoras, servicio técnico lavavajillas, servicio tecnico de frigorificos, servicio técnico de termos, servicio técnico de cocinas y hornos ,servicio tecnico de aire acondicionado de todas las marcas. De esta forma conseguimos ahorrar al cliente una perdida de tiempo importante, a la vez que se reduce el precio de reparacion. Ofrecemos el mejor servicio oficial a precios muy económicos.respetando la elección de cada propietario.

  10. Nosotros lo sabemos porque llevamos más de una década dedicándonos a las reparaciones de cualquier tipo de electrodomésticos, y encargándonos del servicio técnico de las marcas y fabricantes de mayor uso en Guipúzcoa. Ofrecemos un servicio pensado exclusivamente para usted, para que alargue la vida de los electrodomésticos más importantes de su hogar: frigoríficos, lavavajillas, hornos, vitrocerámicas, campanas, y también termos eléctricos, lavadoras secadoras. Simplemente contacte con nuestro servicio de reparacion de electrodomesticos Donostia, y nos encargaremos de dejarle el electrodoméstico como nuevo a un precio más que razonable.

  11. Además, disponen de una gran selección de equipos de aire acondicionado y climatización, ofreciendo al cliente calidad y garantía de las mejores marcas y fabricantes. Solicite presupuesto sin compromiso para la instalación de bombas de calor, aire acondicionado, sistema contra-incendios, ventilación industrial, rejillas de ventilación, maquinaria de hostelería y frío industrial para su empresa.

  12. Este problema es bastante común en zonas costeras con alta humedad porque se ha dejado demasiado tiempo la puerta de la nevera abierta, y se forma hielo en el conducto de retorno del aire que une las 2 partes refrigerador-congelador. Luego se resetea (desconectando del interruptor general de la casa, no vale solo del boton ON-OFF de la nevera), y se espera unos minutos a que vuelva a funcionar. Hola German, te esrcibi alla por el 24 de Diciembre 2011 y me contestaste el de Enero, hoy vino el tecnico y si aparemtemente es el damper tarjeta de control.

  13. En mi caso compré este cacharro para hacer el regalo del día del padre llevado por la propaganda del fácil de usar” y pensando que lo instalaría y me olvidaría de él. A los dos meses tres después de una actualización de firmware fallida (supongo) en el display apareció Err” y ya no pude salir de ahí. La verdad es que no espero respuesta y la lectura de los comentarios de otros usuarios hace que en caso de tenerla no le daría la más mínima credibilidad. Yo no tengo porque contestar a como arreglar un error que yo no veo, que ni soy técnico de sintonizadores TDT, solo un usuario.

  14. Se solicita personal de SEXO FEMENINO, que cumpla con las siguientes características: – SOLTERA SIN HIJOS – CON EXPERIENCIA EN VENTAS Y/ IMPULSACIÓN – Excelente Presencia – Entre 20 y 28 años – Honrada – Puntual – Estable El Horario de trabajo es el siguiente: – Lunes a Viernes: 3:30 pm. a 8:30 pm. – Sábados: 9:45 am. a 9:00 pm. La remuneración es el Sueldo Básico + Beneficios de Ley Favor enviar hoja de vida con foto actualizada al correo electrónico.

  15. Esta tecnología, también se aplica en la fabricación de piezas bajo plano, únicas ó en serie, en cualquier tipo de material plástico. De ahí viene la inclusión de sistemas operativos como el control numérico computarizado CN el cual programa las tareas demandadas a la máquina-herramienta.

  16. Nuestra empresa de mecanizados en Barcelona M.U.R. S.L. les ofrece todo su potencial para ser su proveedor de confianza, en la fabricación de toda clase de piezas metálicas a medida, útiles para el mantenimiento industrial, y cualquier tipo de pieza especial que precise de mecanizado, tanto en pequeñas como en medianas series.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *